Thiyagarajan Arun, Grant Calum, Griffiths Frances, Atherton Helen
Honorary Research Fellow, Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Warwick, UK.
Medical Student, Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Warwick, UK.
BJGP Open. 2020 May 1;4(1). doi: 10.3399/bjgpopen20X101020. Print 2020.
Video consultation (VC) is an emerging consultation mode in general practice. The challenges and benefits of implementing it are not necessarily realised until it is in use, and being experienced by patients and clinicians. To date, there has been no review of the evidence about how patients and clinicians experience VC in general practice.
The study aimed to explore both patients' and clinicians' experiences of VCs in primary care.
DESIGN & SETTING: A systematic scoping review was carried out of empirical studies.
All major databases were searched for empirical studies of any design, published from 1 January 2010 to 11 October 2018 in the English language. Studies were included where synchronous VCs occurred between a patient and a clinician in a primary care setting. Outcomes of interest related to experience of use. The quality of included studies were assessed. Findings were analysed using narrative synthesis.
Seven studies were included in the review. Patients reported being satisfied with VC, describing reduced waiting times and travel costs as a benefit. For patients and clinicians, VC was not deemed appropriate for all presentations and all situations, and a face-to-face consultation was seen as preferable where this was possible.
The findings of this scoping review show that primary care patients and clinicians report both positive and negative experiences when using VCs, and these experiences are, to a certain extent, context dependent. VC is potentially more convenient for patients, but is not considered superior to a face-to-face consultation. Accounts of experience are useful in the planning and implementation of any VC service.
视频会诊(VC)是全科医疗中一种新兴的会诊模式。在其投入使用并被患者和临床医生体验之前,实施它所面临的挑战和益处不一定能被认识到。迄今为止,尚未有关于患者和临床医生在全科医疗中如何体验视频会诊的证据综述。
本研究旨在探索患者和临床医生在初级医疗中对视频会诊的体验。
对实证研究进行了系统的范围综述。
检索了所有主要数据库,查找2010年1月1日至2018年10月11日以英文发表的任何设计的实证研究。纳入的研究需是在初级医疗环境中患者与临床医生之间进行同步视频会诊的情况。感兴趣的结果与使用体验相关。对纳入研究的质量进行了评估。采用叙述性综合分析结果。
该综述纳入了7项研究。患者报告对视频会诊感到满意,称其好处是减少了等待时间和交通成本。对于患者和临床医生而言,视频会诊并不被认为适用于所有病情和所有情况,在可能的情况下,面对面会诊被视为更可取。
这项范围综述的结果表明,初级医疗中的患者和临床医生在使用视频会诊时既有积极体验也有消极体验,而且这些体验在一定程度上取决于具体情况。视频会诊对患者可能更方便,但并不被认为优于面对面会诊。体验描述对任何视频会诊服务的规划和实施都很有用。