Department of Computer Science, University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Dortmund, Germany.
Institute of Medical Informatics, Biometry and Epidemiology, University Hospital Essen, Essen, Germany.
Appl Clin Inform. 2020 Mar;11(2):200-209. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1705105. Epub 2020 Mar 18.
Colorectal cancer is the most commonly occurring cancer in Germany, and the second and third most commonly diagnosed cancer in women and men, respectively. In this context, evidence-based guidelines positively impact the quality of treatment processes for cancer patients. However, evidence of their impact on real-world patient care remains unclear. To ensure the success of clinical guidelines, a fast and clear provision of knowledge at the point of care is essential.
The objectives of this study are to model machine-readable clinical algorithms for colon carcinoma and rectal carcinoma annotated by Unified Medical Language System (UMLS) based on clinical guidelines and the development of an open-source workflow system for mapping clinical algorithms with patient-specific information to identify patient's position on the treatment algorithm for guideline-based therapy recommendations.
This study qualitatively assesses the therapy decision of clinical algorithms as part of a clinical pathway. The solution uses rule-based clinical algorithms, which were developed based on the corresponding guidelines. These algorithms are executed on a newly developed open-source workflow system and are visualized at the point of care. The aim of this approach is to create clinical algorithms based on an established business process standard, the Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN), which is annotated by UMLS terminologies. The gold standard for the validation process was set by manual extraction of clinical datasets from 86 rectal cancer patients and 89 colon cancer patients.
Using this approach, the algorithm achieved a precision value of 87.64% for colon cancer and 84.70% for rectal cancer with recall values of 87.64 and 83.72%, respectively.
The results indicate that the automatic positioning of a patient on the decision pathway is possible with tumor stages that have a less complex clinical algorithm with fewer decision points reaching a higher accuracy than complex stages.
结直肠癌是德国最常见的癌症,也是女性和男性中第二和第三常见的癌症。在这种情况下,基于证据的指南对癌症患者的治疗过程质量有积极影响。然而,其对实际患者护理的影响证据尚不清楚。为了确保临床指南的成功,在护理点快速清晰地提供知识至关重要。
本研究的目的是为基于临床指南注释的统一医学语言系统(UMLS)的结肠癌和直肠癌建立机器可读的临床算法,并开发一个开源工作流系统,用于将临床算法与患者特定信息进行映射,以识别患者在基于指南的治疗建议治疗算法中的位置。
本研究定性评估了临床算法作为临床路径一部分的治疗决策。该解决方案使用基于规则的临床算法,这些算法是基于相应的指南开发的。这些算法在新开发的开源工作流系统上执行,并在护理点可视化。这种方法的目的是基于已建立的业务流程标准(业务流程模型和符号(BPMN))创建临床算法,该标准由 UMLS 术语注释。验证过程的金标准是通过从 86 例直肠癌患者和 89 例结肠癌患者中手动提取临床数据集来设定的。
使用这种方法,对于结肠癌,算法的精度值为 87.64%,对于直肠癌,精度值为 84.70%,召回率分别为 87.64%和 83.72%。
结果表明,对于具有较少决策点且临床算法较简单的肿瘤阶段,自动定位患者在决策路径上是可能的,并且比复杂阶段具有更高的准确性。