Big Sky Health Analytics, Vermilion, AB, Canada.
Public Health Risk Sciences Division, National Microbiology Laboratory, Public Health Agency of Canada, Guelph, ON, Canada.
Zoonoses Public Health. 2020 Jun;67(4):391-406. doi: 10.1111/zph.12698. Epub 2020 Mar 20.
The reported incidence of clinical hepatitis E cases is rising in some non-endemic countries, with concurrent concerns regarding potential hepatitis E virus (HEV) contamination of the blood supply. Therefore, the characterization of major potential sources of human HEV exposure is important to inform risk assessment and public health policy. A systematic review was conducted, including a comprehensive search in six electronic bibliographic databases, verified by hand-searching reference lists of HEV reviews, and a grey literature search, of the broad research question 'what is the evidence of the association between predictors of human HEV exposure, and HEV IgG seropositivity, in non-endemic countries?' Using forms designed a priori, captured studies were appraised at first-level screening, second-level characterization, and third-level data extraction and risk of bias assessment. Meta-analysis yielded summary estimates of association between potential predictors and odds of HEV seropositivity. Meta-analysis and meta-regression of the odds of HEV seroprevalence in specific groups characterized potential sources of HEV exposure. From 4,163 captured citations, 245 relevant studies underwent data extraction, investigating HEV seroprevalence or predictors in both healthy subjects and targeted patient groups. Across these groups, increasing age was a predictor of HEV IgG seropositivity. Both human immunodeficiency virus patients and haemodialysis patients had significantly increased odds of HEV seropositivity relative to the general population. Working with pigs, in forestry, or in hospitals, was significantly associated with increased odds of HEV seropositivity, as were consumption of meat, pork or game meat, or hunting. Chronological time was not associated with HEV seropositivity within our data sets. Further study of the distribution of potential dietary or behavioural predictors between high and lower prevalence areas within non-endemic countries could improve our understanding of the relative importance of specific HEV transmission pathways.
在一些非流行国家,临床戊型肝炎病例的报告发病率正在上升,同时人们对血液供应中潜在的戊型肝炎病毒(HEV)污染也存在担忧。因此,确定人类 HEV 暴露的主要潜在来源对于进行风险评估和制定公共卫生政策非常重要。我们进行了一项系统评价,包括在六个电子文献数据库中进行全面搜索,通过检索戊型肝炎评价的参考文献列表进行手工搜索,并对灰色文献进行搜索,以广泛研究问题“在非流行国家,与人类 HEV 暴露预测因素相关的证据与 HEV IgG 血清阳性之间有何关联?”使用预先设计的表格,捕获的研究首先在一级筛选、二级特征描述和三级数据提取和偏倚风险评估中进行评估。对潜在预测因素与 HEV 血清阳性的相关性进行了荟萃分析,以得出汇总估计值。对特定人群 HEV 血清阳性率的优势比进行荟萃分析和荟萃回归,可确定 HEV 暴露的潜在来源。从 4163 个捕获的引用中,有 245 项相关研究进行了数据提取,调查了健康受试者和目标患者群体中 HEV 的血清流行率或预测因素。在这些群体中,年龄的增加是 HEV IgG 血清阳性的一个预测因素。与一般人群相比,人类免疫缺陷病毒患者和血液透析患者的 HEV 血清阳性率显著增加。与猪一起工作、在林业工作或在医院工作与 HEV 血清阳性率的增加显著相关,食用肉类、猪肉或野味或狩猎也是如此。在我们的数据集内,时间的先后顺序与 HEV 血清阳性率无关。在非流行国家内,进一步研究潜在的饮食或行为预测因素在高和低流行地区之间的分布情况,可能会提高我们对特定 HEV 传播途径相对重要性的理解。