Ramos Charmaine G
Dev Change. 2020 Mar;51(2):485-505. doi: 10.1111/dech.12564. Epub 2020 Jan 11.
This article explores social policy reforms championed by the Philippines' strongman president Rodrigo Duterte during his first three years in office (2016-19), as a case for examining the transformative potential of social policy expansion under rising new right-wing and authoritarian leaders. By showing how political economy and historico-institutional conditions foreclose the transformative possibilities of the social policy changes effected by Duterte, the author offers a critique of current tendencies in global development discourses to treat all forms of social policy expansion as progressive. In the Philippines case, there is no progressive ideology guiding the reforms, nor are there political movements overseeing the expansion of social rights now inscribed in law. Rather, the reforms institutionally entrench a minimalist approach to universalism and strengthen the foothold of poverty targeting as an organizing principle of social provisioning. Social policy expansion under Duterte manifests aspects of the 'dark side' of social policy reforms during the current global political moment, including the use of such policy reforms to legitimize a conservative and authoritarian political order, and the functionality, across the political spectrum, of 'narrow universalism' - the type championed by international development agencies - which serves to deepen segmentation in social provisioning.
本文探讨了菲律宾铁腕总统罗德里戈·杜特尔特在其执政的头三年(2016 - 2019年)所倡导的社会政策改革,以此作为一个案例,来审视在新的右翼和威权领导人崛起的背景下社会政策扩张的变革潜力。通过展示政治经济和历史制度条件如何排除了杜特尔特所实施的社会政策变革的变革可能性,作者对全球发展话语中当前将所有形式的社会政策扩张都视为进步的倾向提出了批评。就菲律宾的情况而言,改革没有进步的意识形态作为指导,也没有政治运动监督目前已写入法律的社会权利扩张。相反,这些改革在制度上确立了一种极简主义的普遍主义方法,并强化了将贫困瞄准作为社会供给组织原则的立足点。杜特尔特执政期间的社会政策扩张体现了当前全球政治时刻社会政策改革“黑暗面”的一些方面,包括利用此类政策改革使保守和威权政治秩序合法化,以及在整个政治光谱中“狭义普遍主义”(国际发展机构所倡导的那种类型)的功能性,这种普遍主义加深了社会供给中的分化。