Tornberg Åsa B, Lauruschkus Katarina
Department of Health Sciences, Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
PeerJ. 2020 Mar 17;8:e8561. doi: 10.7717/peerj.8561. eCollection 2020.
The aim of this study was to compare the effects of four months of two types of structured training regimes, static standing (StS) versus dynamic standing (DyS), on passive range of motion (PROM) and spasticity in the hip among non-ambulatory children with cerebral palsy.
Twenty non-ambulatory children with cerebral palsy participated in an exercise intervention study with a crossover design. During StS, the Non-ambulatory children with cerebral palsy were encouraged to exercise according to standard care recommendations, including daily supported StS for 30-90 min. During DyS, daily exercise for at least 30 min at a speed between 30 and 50 rpm in an Innowalk (Made for movement, Norway) was recommended. We assessed adaptive effects from the exercise programs through PROM in the hip assessed with a handheld goniometer, and spasticity in the hip assessed with the Modified Ashworth Scale before and after 30 min of StS or DyS. A trained physiotherapist performed the assessments. The exercise test and exercise training were performed in the children's habitual environment. Non-parametric statistics were used and each leg was used as its own control.
PROM increased in all directions after 30 min ( < 0.001), and after four months of exercise training ( < 0.001) of DyS. Thirty minutes of DyS lowered the spasticity in the muscles around the hip ( < 0.001) more than 30 min of StS ( < 0.001).
Thirty minutes of DyS increased PROM and decreased spasticity among non-ambulatory children with CP. Four months of DyS increased PROM but did not decrease spasticity. These results can help inform individualised standing recommendations.
本研究旨在比较两种结构化训练方案(静态站立[StS]与动态站立[DyS])对非行走型脑瘫儿童髋关节被动活动范围(PROM)和痉挛的影响,训练为期四个月。
20名非行走型脑瘫儿童参与了一项采用交叉设计的运动干预研究。在静态站立期间,鼓励非行走型脑瘫儿童按照标准护理建议进行锻炼,包括每天接受30 - 90分钟的辅助静态站立。在动态站立期间,建议在Innowalk(挪威制造,专为运动设计)上以每分钟30至50转的速度每天至少锻炼30分钟。我们通过使用手持角度计评估髋关节的被动活动范围以及使用改良Ashworth量表评估髋关节痉挛,在静态站立或动态站立30分钟前后评估运动方案的适应性效果。由一名训练有素的物理治疗师进行评估。运动测试和运动训练在儿童的日常环境中进行。使用非参数统计,每条腿作为自身对照。
动态站立30分钟后(P < 0.001)以及动态站立四个月的运动训练后(P < 0.001),各个方向的被动活动范围均增加。30分钟的动态站立比30分钟的静态站立更能降低髋关节周围肌肉的痉挛程度(P < 0.001)。
30分钟的动态站立可增加非行走型脑瘫儿童的被动活动范围并降低痉挛程度。四个月的动态站立可增加被动活动范围,但并未降低痉挛程度。这些结果有助于为个性化站立建议提供参考。