Department of Environmental Toxicology, The Institute of Environmental and Human Health, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas 79416, United States.
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas 79409, United States.
Environ Sci Technol. 2020 May 5;54(9):5651-5666. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.9b07657. Epub 2020 Apr 20.
Various anthropogenic activities simultaneously alter essential mineral nutrients and contaminant content in the environment. Depending on essential nutrient conditions, the uptake and effects of contaminants in exposed organisms may be altered. The addressing of ecological risk assessment (ERA) of contaminant mixtures has proven difficult. Furthermore, most assessments involving single contaminant exposures do not consider the interaction of essential nutrients on toxicological end points. Hypotheses for toxicological effects of cadmium (Cd), arsenic (As), and their binary mixture (Cd/As) include alteration under varying dietary and media phosphorus (P) conditions. However, interactive effects and effect size (η) are largely unknown. Here, we investigated the toxicities of Cd-, As-, and Cd/As-treated media and diets on (a primary producer) and (a primary consumer), under varied media and dietary P conditions [low (LP), median (MP), and optimum (COMBO)]. Our results showed significant ( < 0.05) interactive effects and concentration dependent growth inhibition of . The toxicity (at day 7) of Cd against was 2×, 11×, and 4× that of As in LP, MP, and COMBO conditions, respectively, while the joint toxicity effects of Cd/As were partially additive in LP and COMBO, and synergistic in MP media. Furthermore, acute lethal toxicity (96 h) of Cd in was ∼60× that of As, while Cd/As joint toxicity was synergistic. Chronic toxicity (14 d) in showed significant ( < 0.05) interaction of As and P-availability on survival, reproduction, and behavior (distance moved, velocity, acceleration and mobility), while Cd and P availability showed significant interactive effect on rotational behavior. Dose response effects of Cd, As, and Cd/As in and were either monophasic or biphasic under varying nutrient conditions. This study provides empirical evidence of the interactive effects of media/dietary P and toxic metals (Cd, As, and Cd/As) at environmentally relevant concentrations, emphasizing the need for consideration of such interactions during ERA.
各种人为活动同时改变了环境中基本矿物质营养物和污染物的含量。根据基本营养条件的不同,暴露于污染物中的生物体对污染物的吸收和影响可能会发生改变。证明了混合污染物的生态风险评估 (ERA) 具有一定难度。此外,大多数涉及单一污染物暴露的评估都没有考虑基本营养物对毒理学终点的相互作用。镉 (Cd)、砷 (As) 及其二元混合物 (Cd/As) 的毒性作用假说包括在不同的饮食和介质磷 (P) 条件下的改变。然而,相互作用的影响和影响大小 (η) 在很大程度上是未知的。在这里,我们在不同的介质和饮食 P 条件下 [低 (LP)、中 (MP) 和最佳 (COMBO)],研究了 Cd-、As- 和 Cd/As 处理的介质和饮食对 (初级生产者)和 (初级消费者)的毒性,结果表明存在显著的( < 0.05)相互作用和浓度依赖性生长抑制。在 LP、MP 和 COMBO 条件下,Cd 对 的毒性(第 7 天)分别是 As 的 2 倍、11 倍和 4 倍,而 Cd/As 的联合毒性效应在 LP 和 COMBO 中部分相加,在 MP 介质中协同作用。此外,Cd 在 中的急性致死毒性(96 h)约为 As 的 60 倍,而 Cd/As 的联合毒性则协同作用。在 中,14 天的慢性毒性显示出 As 和 P 可用性对存活率、繁殖率和行为(移动距离、速度、加速度和移动性)的显著相互作用,而 Cd 和 P 可用性对旋转行为显示出显著的相互作用。在不同营养条件下,Cd、As 和 Cd/As 在 和 中的剂量反应效应是单峰或双峰的。这项研究提供了环境相关浓度下介质/饮食 P 和有毒金属(Cd、As 和 Cd/As)相互作用的实验证据,强调了在 ERA 期间需要考虑这种相互作用。