Kang Lili, Ye Shangyuan, Jing Kangzhen, Fan Yancun, Chen Qihui, Zhang Ning, Zhang Bo
Center for Health Policy and Management Studies, Nanjing University, Nanjing, Jiangsu, People's Republic of China.
School of Health Management, Inner Mongolia Medical University, Hohhot, Inner Mongolia, People's Republic of China.
Risk Manag Healthc Policy. 2020 Mar 19;13:245-253. doi: 10.2147/RMHP.S230923. eCollection 2020.
This study evaluated change in caesarean section rate with reform of birth planning policy in China from one-child to two-child policy.
Study data were collected from patient-level hospital records of 59,668 pregnant women who visited three major urban hospitals in Jiangsu Province and Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region of China between January 2012 and December 2016. A segmented logistic regression approach was developed to evaluate the changes in caesarean section rate in these regions with the launch of China's new partial and universal two-child policies in January 2014 and January 2016, respectively.
Jiangsu Province had a significantly lower non-emergency caesarean rate (Jiangsu 8.15% vs Inner Mongolia 34.03%, < 0.001) and a much lower percentage of minority population (Jiangsu 6.99% vs Inner Mongolia 21.76%, < 0.001) than Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region. In Jiangsu Province, no change in caesarean section rate was detected with the two-child policies (all -values > 0.05), although the unadjusted trend change (0.038, 95% confidence interval or CI: [0.016, 0.060], < 0.001) in log odds after the implementation of the partial two-child policy was statistically significant. In Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, an immediate jump in caesarean section rate was discovered by the segmented logistic regression with the implementation of both the partial (unadjusted level change 0.297, CI: [0.105, 0.489], = 0.002) and universal two-child policies (unadjusted level change 1.945, CI: [1.277, 2.614], < 0.001); but the rate reverted to the previous level thereafter. Ethnicity, maternal age, maternal reproduction history, insurance coverage type, infant weight, and infant gender were the significant factors associated with caesarean section rate (for odds ratios, all -values < 0.05). However, the significance of infant gender may stem from the large sample size of the study and is not clinically meaningful.
Change in caesarean section rate was not observed with the launch of two-child policy in China.
本研究评估了中国计划生育政策从独生子女政策改革为二孩政策后剖宫产率的变化。
研究数据收集自2012年1月至2016年12月期间在中国江苏省和内蒙古自治区三家大型城市医院就诊的59668名孕妇的个体医院记录。采用分段逻辑回归方法,分别评估随着中国新的部分二孩政策和全面二孩政策于2014年1月和2016年1月推出,这些地区剖宫产率的变化。
江苏省的非急诊剖宫产率(江苏省8.15%,内蒙古自治区34.03%,P<0.001)显著低于内蒙古自治区,少数民族人口比例(江苏省6.99%,内蒙古自治区21.76%,P<0.001)也远低于内蒙古自治区。在江苏省,二孩政策实施后未检测到剖宫产率的变化(所有P值>0.05),尽管部分二孩政策实施后对数优势的未调整趋势变化(0.038,95%置信区间或CI:[0.016,0.060],P<0.001)具有统计学意义。在内蒙古自治区,分段逻辑回归显示随着部分二孩政策(未调整水平变化0.297,CI:[0.105,0.489],P=0.002)和全面二孩政策(未调整水平变化1.945,CI:[1.277,2.614],P<0.001)的实施,剖宫产率立即跃升;但此后该比率又恢复到先前水平。种族、产妇年龄、产妇生育史、保险覆盖类型、婴儿体重和婴儿性别是与剖宫产率相关的显著因素(对于比值比,所有P值<0.05)。然而,婴儿性别的显著性可能源于研究样本量较大,并无临床意义。
中国二孩政策推出后未观察到剖宫产率的变化。