Shah Ashish H, Mahavadi Anil K, Morell Alexis, Eichberg Daniel G, Luther Evan, Sarkiss Christopher A, Semonche Alexa, Ivan Michael E, Komotar Ricardo J
Department of Neurosurgery, University of Miami, FL, USA.
Neurooncol Pract. 2020 Jan;7(1):94-102. doi: 10.1093/nop/npz028. Epub 2019 Jul 3.
The incidence of symptomatic radiation necrosis (RN) has risen as radiotherapy is increasingly used to control brain tumor progression. Traditionally managed with steroids, symptomatic RN can remain refractory to medical treatment, requiring surgical intervention for control. The purpose of our study was to assess a single institution's experience with craniotomy for steroid-refractory pure RN.
The medical records of all tumor patients who underwent craniotomies at our institution from 2011 to 2016 were retrospectively reviewed for a history of preoperative radiotherapy or radiosurgery. RN was confirmed histopathologically and patients with active tumor were excluded. Preoperative, intraoperative, and outcome information was collected. Primary outcomes measured were postoperative KPS and time to steroid freedom.
Twenty-four patients with symptomatic RN were identified. Gross total resection was achieved for all patients. Patients with metastases experienced an increase in KPS (80 vs 100, < .001) and required a shortened course of dexamethasone vs patients with high-grade gliomas (3.4 vs 22.2 weeks, = .003). RN control and neurological improvement at 13.3 months' follow-up were 100% and 66.7%, respectively. Adrenal insufficiency after rapidly tapering dexamethasone was the only morbidity (n = 1). Overall survival was 93.3% (14/15) at 1 year.
In cases of treatment-refractory symptomatic RN, resection can lead to an overall improvement in postoperative health status and neurological outcomes with minimal RN recurrence. Craniotomy for surgically accessible RN can safely manage symptomatic patients, and future studies assessing the efficacy of resection vs bevacizumab may be warranted.
随着放射治疗越来越多地用于控制脑肿瘤进展,有症状的放射性坏死(RN)的发生率有所上升。有症状的RN传统上用类固醇治疗,但可能对药物治疗仍有抵抗,需要手术干预来控制。我们研究的目的是评估单一机构对类固醇难治性单纯RN进行开颅手术的经验。
回顾性分析2011年至2016年在我们机构接受开颅手术的所有肿瘤患者的病历,以了解术前放疗或放射外科手术史。通过组织病理学确诊为RN,并排除有活动性肿瘤的患者。收集术前、术中和预后信息。主要测量的结局指标是术后KPS评分和停用类固醇的时间。
确定了24例有症状的RN患者。所有患者均实现了肉眼全切。与高级别胶质瘤患者相比,转移瘤患者的KPS评分有所提高(80 vs 100,P<0.001),地塞米松疗程缩短(3.4 vs 22.2周,P = 0.003)。随访13.3个月时,RN得到控制和神经功能改善的比例分别为100%和66.7%。快速减量地塞米松后出现的肾上腺功能不全是唯一的并发症(n = 1)。1年总生存率为93.3%(14/15)。
在治疗难治性有症状的RN病例中,切除可使术后健康状况和神经功能结局总体改善,RN复发极少。对可手术切除的RN进行开颅手术可安全地治疗有症状的患者,未来有必要开展评估切除与贝伐单抗疗效的研究。