Oklahoma State University, United States.
College of the Holy Cross, United States.
Soc Sci Res. 2020 Mar;87:102402. doi: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2019.102402. Epub 2019 Dec 28.
We propose an institutionalization of part-time work model to account for the cross-national variation in workers' perceptions of insecurity in their jobs and in the labor market, arguing that part-time work is institutionalized as high quality or marginal employment depending on the extent to which it is voluntary, gendered, and legally protected. Using heterogeneous choice models on 2005 ISSP data linked to country-level characteristics, we find that the relationship between part-time work and insecurity is gendered and contingent upon the type of insecurity (cognitive job insecurity, labor market insecurity, or affective job insecurity) and whether or not one works part-time on a voluntary basis. At the individual level, working in a part-time job is associated with greater cognitive job insecurity but lower labor market and affective job insecurity. At the national level, the expected negative association between the part-time work rate and insecurity is most consistent for affective job insecurity. The findings also indicate that the strength of the association between working in a part-time job and insecurity varies by the national institutional context of part-time work, including the degree of gender segregation of part-time work and legal protections for part-time workers. Overall, the results from this study provide support for our institutionalization of part-time work perspective. Part-time work is not inherently secure or insecure employment. The amount of insecurity associated with this type of non-standard work is contingent upon the prevailing local myths or scripts that structure the ways that the state, employers, and workers view part-time work.
我们提出了一种兼职工作模式的制度化,以解释工人对工作和劳动力市场不安全感的跨国差异,认为兼职工作是高质量的还是边缘性的就业,取决于其自愿性、性别和法律保护程度。我们使用 2005 年国际社会调查项目(ISSP)数据与国家层面特征相联系的异质选择模型,发现兼职工作与不安全感之间的关系具有性别差异,并取决于不安全感的类型(认知工作不安全感、劳动力市场不安全感或情感工作不安全感)以及是否基于自愿兼职。在个人层面上,从事兼职工作与更大的认知工作不安全感相关,但与劳动力市场和情感工作不安全感较低相关。在国家层面上,兼职工作率与不安全感之间的负相关预期在情感工作不安全感方面最为一致。研究结果还表明,兼职工作与不安全感之间的关联强度因兼职工作的国家制度背景而异,包括兼职工作的性别隔离程度和对兼职工人的法律保护程度。总的来说,这项研究的结果支持了我们对兼职工作制度化的观点。兼职工作本身并不是安全或不安全的就业形式。这种非标准工作类型所带来的不安全感程度取决于当前的地方神话或脚本,这些神话或脚本构建了国家、雇主和工人对兼职工作的看法。