Vall d'Hebron University Hospital; Autonomous University of Barcelona.
Hospital del Mar.
Transcult Psychiatry. 2021 Feb;58(1):126-139. doi: 10.1177/1363461520916697. Epub 2020 Apr 11.
We examine whether patient variables (geographic origin, gender, Spanish language proficiency) and subjective clinician aspects in emergency department psychiatric encounters (diagnostic certainty, clinician's comfort level with patient) are associated with diagnosis and the use of coercive measures. Using a descriptive cross-sectional design, we recorded 467 visits (400 foreign-born and 67 native-born patients) in hospital psychiatry emergency rooms (ERs) in Barcelona between 2007 and 2015. We first assessed the association of patient variables and subjective clinician aspects of psychiatric encounters with service use outcomes and with mental illness diagnosis. Fitted logistic models predicted the likelihood of service use outcomes and estimated the propensity of receiving each diagnosis. The null model evaluated the role of patient's geographical origin, while the full model evaluated the additional roles of patient's gender and language, the clinician's assessment of the influence of culture in diagnosis, and clinician comfort with two outcomes: patient's diagnosis and use of coercive measures in the ER. Women were less likely to receive coercive measures or intramuscular medications compared to men. Significant ethnic/racial and gender differences were found in receiving certain diagnoses. Additionally, a patient's lower Spanish proficiency was correlated with a higher probability of receiving a psychosis diagnosis. The clinician's level of diagnostic certainty was also positively correlated with increasing clinician-reported comfort with patient. Overall, ethnic factors and the subjective aspects of psychiatric encounters were found to influence diagnosis and the use of coercive measures. Cultural competency programs and interpreter services within psychiatric ER settings should thus be required.
我们考察了患者变量(地理来源、性别、西班牙语熟练程度)和急诊室精神科医生的主观临床方面(诊断确定性、医生对患者的舒适程度)是否与诊断和强制性措施的使用有关。我们使用描述性的横断面设计,记录了 2007 年至 2015 年间巴塞罗那医院精神科急诊室的 467 次就诊(400 名外国出生和 67 名本地出生的患者)。我们首先评估了精神科就诊中患者变量和主观临床方面与服务使用结果以及精神疾病诊断的相关性。拟合的逻辑模型预测了服务使用结果的可能性,并估计了每种诊断的倾向。空模型评估了患者地理来源的作用,而全模型评估了患者性别和语言、医生对文化对诊断影响的评估,以及医生对两个结果的舒适程度(患者的诊断和在急诊室使用强制性措施)的额外作用。与男性相比,女性接受强制性措施或肌肉注射药物的可能性较小。在接受某些诊断方面发现了显著的种族/民族和性别差异。此外,患者西班牙语熟练度较低与患精神病的可能性增加有关。医生的诊断确定性水平也与医生报告的对患者的舒适度增加呈正相关。总的来说,种族因素和精神科急诊室的主观方面被发现会影响诊断和强制性措施的使用。因此,应该在精神科急诊室设置文化能力计划和口译服务。