Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, the National Clinician Scholars Program, the Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation, the Program on Women's Healthcare Effectiveness Research (PWHER), and the Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Obstet Gynecol. 2020 May;135(5):1038-1046. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000003731.
To describe patients' preferences for prenatal and postpartum care delivery.
We conducted a cross-sectional survey of postpartum patients admitted for childbirth and recovery at an academic institution. We assessed patient preferences for prenatal and postpartum care delivery, including visit number, between-visit contact (eg, phone and electronic medical record portal communication), acceptability of remote monitoring (eg, weight, blood pressure, fetal heart tones), and alternative care models (eg, telemedicine and home visits). We compared preferences for prenatal care visit number to current American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists' recommendations (12-14 prenatal visits).
Of the 332 women eligible for the study, 300 (90%) completed the survey. Women desired a median number of 10 prenatal visits (interquartile range 9-12), with most desiring fewer visits than currently recommended (fewer than 12: 63% [n=189]; 12-14: 22% [n=65]; more than 14: 15% [n=46]). Women who had private insurance or were white were more likely to prefer fewer prenatal visits. The majority of patients desired contact with their care team between visits (84%). Most patients reported comfort with home monitoring skills, including measuring weight (91%), blood pressure (82%), and fetal heart tones (68%). Patients reported that they would be most likely to use individual care models (94%), followed by pregnancy medical homes (72%) and home visits (69%). The majority of patients desired at least two postpartum visits (91%), with the first visit within 3 weeks after discharge (81%).
Current prenatal and postpartum care delivery does not match patients' preferences for visit number or between-visit contact, and patients are open to alternative models of prenatal care, including remote monitoring. Future prenatal care redesign will need to consider diverse patients' preferences and flexible models of care that are tailored to work with patients in the context of their lives and communities.
描述患者对产前和产后护理服务的偏好。
我们对在学术机构分娩和康复的产后患者进行了横断面调查。我们评估了患者对产前和产后护理服务的偏好,包括就诊次数、就诊间的联系(如电话和电子病历门户沟通)、远程监测的可接受性(如体重、血压、胎心音)以及替代护理模式(如远程医疗和家访)。我们将产前就诊次数的偏好与美国妇产科医师学会目前的建议(12-14 次产前就诊)进行了比较。
在符合研究条件的 332 名女性中,有 300 名(90%)完成了调查。女性期望中位数为 10 次产前就诊(四分位距为 9-12 次),大多数人希望就诊次数少于目前建议的次数(少于 12 次:63%[189 人];12-14 次:22%[65 人];超过 14 次:15%[46 人])。有私人保险或白人的女性更倾向于就诊次数较少。大多数患者希望在就诊间与护理团队保持联系(84%)。大多数患者报告对家庭监测技能感到舒适,包括测量体重(91%)、血压(82%)和胎心音(68%)。患者表示最有可能使用个人护理模式(94%),其次是妊娠医疗之家(72%)和家访(69%)。大多数患者希望至少进行两次产后就诊(91%),其中第一次就诊在出院后 3 周内(81%)。
目前的产前和产后护理服务与患者对就诊次数或就诊间联系的偏好不匹配,患者对远程监测等替代产前护理模式持开放态度。未来的产前护理重新设计需要考虑到不同患者的偏好和灵活的护理模式,这些模式需要根据患者的生活和社区环境进行定制。