Graham G P, Fairclough J A
Cardiff Royal Infirmary.
Injury. 1988 Jul;19(4):247-8. doi: 10.1016/0020-1383(88)90037-x.
In a retrospective study of patients presenting with symptoms of knee instability, 16 patients were discovered who had developed severe chondromalacia or osteoarthritis of the femoral condyles. All of the patients gave a history of a previous severe knee injury occurring in their teenage years and all had continued to play competitive sport. Ten of the group had subsequent meniscal injuries requiring surgery. In nine of the group previous arthroscopic or open joint procedures had demonstrated normal femoral joint cartilage. There was no difference in the degree of degeneration in those who had had a meniscectomy as compared with those who had not had meniscal damage. It is concluded that severe anterolateral instability is a cause of early degenerative joint disease in young athletes even in the absence of meniscal damage and that they should be strongly advised against participating in active sport until the joint has been stabilized.
在一项针对出现膝关节不稳定症状患者的回顾性研究中,发现16例患者出现了股骨髁严重软骨软化或骨关节炎。所有患者都有青少年时期严重膝关节损伤的病史,并且都继续参加竞技运动。该组中有10例随后出现半月板损伤需要手术治疗。该组中有9例之前的关节镜检查或开放性关节手术显示股骨关节软骨正常。与未发生半月板损伤的患者相比,行半月板切除术的患者退变程度没有差异。得出的结论是,即使没有半月板损伤,严重的前外侧不稳定也是年轻运动员早期退行性关节病的一个原因,并且应强烈建议他们在关节稳定之前不要参加剧烈运动。