Department of Nuclear Medicine, Chinese PLA General Hospital, Beijing, 100853, China.
UIH America, Inc, Houston, TX, 75054, USA.
Med Phys. 2021 May;48(5):2160-2169. doi: 10.1002/mp.14187. Epub 2021 Mar 31.
Parametric imaging using the Patlak model has been shown to provide improved lesion detectability and specificity. The Patlak model requires both tissue time-activity curves (TACs) after equilibrium and knowledge of the input function from the start of injection. Therefore, the conventional dynamic scanning protocol typically starts from the radiotracer injection all the way to equilibrium. In this paper, we propose the use of hybrid population-based and model-based input function estimation and evaluate its use for whole-body Patlak analysis, in order to reduce the total scan time and simplify clinical Patlak parametric imaging protocols. Possible quantitative errors caused by the simplified scanning protocol were also analyzed both theoretically and with the use of clinical data.
Clinical data from 24 patients referred for tumor staging were included in this study. The patients underwent a whole-body dynamic PET study, 20 min after FDG injection (0.13 mCi/kg). The proposed whole-body scanning protocol includes 6 passes with 4-5 bed positions, depending on the size of the patient, with 2 min for each bed position. An input function from the literature was selected as the shape of the population-based input function. The descending aorta from the corresponding CT image was segmented and applied on the reconstructed dynamic PET images to acquire an image-based input function, which was later fitted using an exponential model. Due to the late scan time, only the later portion of the input function was available, which was used to scale the population-based input function. The hybrid input function was used to derive the whole-body Patlak images. Assuming a given error in the population-based input function, its influence on the final Patlak images were also derived theoretically and verified using the clinical data sets. Finally, the image quality of the reconstructed Patlak slope image was evaluated by an experienced radiologist in four different aspects: image artifacts, image noise, lesion sharpness, and lesion detectability.
It was found that errors in the population-based input function only affect the absolute scale of the Patlak slope image. The induced error is proportional to the percentage area-under-curve (AUC) error in the input function. These findings were also confirmed by numerical analysis. The predicted global scale was in good agreement with results from both image-based Patlak and direct Patlak approach. The fractions of the AUC from the early portion population-based input function were also found to be around 18% of the total AUC of the input function, further limiting the propagation of quantitation error from population-based input function to the final Patlak slope image. The reconstructed Patlak images were also found by the radiologist to provide excellent confidence in lesion detection tasks.
We have proposed a simplified whole-body scanning protocol that utilizes both population-based input function and model-based input function. The error from the population-based function was found to only affect the global scale and the overall quantitative impact can be predicted using our proposed formulas.
使用 Patlak 模型进行参数成像已被证明可以提高病变的检测能力和特异性。Patlak 模型需要在平衡后获取组织时间-活性曲线(TAC),并从注射开始就了解输入函数。因此,传统的动态扫描方案通常从放射性示踪剂注射一直持续到平衡。在本文中,我们提出了使用混合基于群体和基于模型的输入函数估计,并评估其在全身 Patlak 分析中的用途,以减少总扫描时间并简化临床 Patlak 参数成像方案。还从理论和临床数据两方面分析了简化扫描方案引起的可能定量误差。
本研究纳入了 24 名因肿瘤分期而接受检查的患者的临床数据。患者在 FDG 注射后 20 分钟(0.13mCi/kg)进行全身动态 PET 检查。建议的全身扫描方案包括 6 次扫描,每次扫描使用 4-5 个床位位置,具体取决于患者的大小,每个床位位置需要 2 分钟。选择文献中的输入函数作为基于群体的输入函数的形状。从相应的 CT 图像分割降主动脉,并应用于重建的动态 PET 图像以获取基于图像的输入函数,然后使用指数模型对其进行拟合。由于扫描时间较晚,仅可用输入函数的后期部分,该部分用于缩放基于群体的输入函数。使用混合输入函数得出全身 Patlak 图像。假设基于群体的输入函数存在给定误差,还从理论上推导了其对最终 Patlak 图像的影响,并使用临床数据集进行了验证。最后,一位有经验的放射科医生从四个方面评估了重建的 Patlak 斜率图像的图像质量:图像伪影、图像噪声、病变锐利度和病变检出率。
研究发现,基于群体的输入函数中的误差仅影响 Patlak 斜率图像的绝对标度。诱导误差与输入函数中的曲线下面积(AUC)误差百分比成正比。这些发现也得到了数值分析的证实。预测的全局标度与基于图像的 Patlak 和直接 Patlak 方法的结果非常吻合。还发现,基于群体的输入函数早期部分的 AUC 分数约占输入函数总 AUC 的 18%,这进一步限制了定量误差从基于群体的输入函数传播到最终的 Patlak 斜率图像。放射科医生还发现,重建的 Patlak 图像在检测病变任务中提供了出色的信心。
我们提出了一种简化的全身扫描方案,该方案同时使用基于群体的输入函数和基于模型的输入函数。发现基于群体的函数的误差仅影响全局标度,并且可以使用我们提出的公式来预测整体定量影响。