Sagol school of Neuroscience, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Dept. of Physical Therapy, Stanley Steyer School of Health Professions, Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Sci Rep. 2020 Apr 24;10(1):6932. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-63999-1.
Analogies have been shown to improve motor learning in various tasks and settings. In this study we tested whether applying analogies can shorten the motor learning process and induce insight and skill improvement in tasks that usually demand many hours of practice. Kinematic measures were used to quantify participant's skill and learning dynamics. For this purpose, we used a drawing task, in which subjects drew lines to connect dots, and a mirror game, in which subjects tracked a moving stimulus. After establishing a baseline, subjects were given an analogy, explicit instructions or no further instruction. We compared their improvement in skill (quantified by coarticulation or smoothness), accuracy and movement duration. Subjects in the analogy and explicit groups improved their coarticulation in the target task, while significant differences were found in the mirror game only at a slow movement frequency between analogy and controls.We conclude that a verbal analogy can be a useful tool for rapidly changing motor kinematics and movement strategy in some circumstances, although in the tasks selected it did not produce better performance in most measurements than explicit guidance. Furthermore, we observed that different movement facets may improve independently from others, and may be selectively affected by verbal instructions. These results suggest an important role for the type of instruction in motor learning.
类比已被证明可以在各种任务和环境中提高运动学习效果。在这项研究中,我们测试了类比是否可以缩短运动学习过程,并在通常需要大量练习的任务中引发顿悟和技能提高。运动学测量用于量化参与者的技能和学习动态。为此,我们使用了一项绘图任务,参与者在其中绘制线条以连接点,以及一项镜像游戏,参与者在其中跟踪移动的刺激。在建立基线后,为参与者提供类比、明确的指导或没有进一步的指导。我们比较了他们在技能(通过共动或平滑度来量化)、准确性和运动持续时间方面的提高。类比和明确指导组的参与者在目标任务中的共动得到了改善,而在镜像游戏中,仅在慢运动频率下,类比组与对照组之间存在显著差异。我们得出的结论是,在某些情况下,口头类比可以成为快速改变运动运动学和运动策略的有用工具,尽管在所选任务中,它在大多数测量中并没有比明确指导产生更好的性能。此外,我们观察到不同的运动方面可能会独立于其他方面得到改善,并且可能会受到口头指令的选择性影响。这些结果表明,指令类型在运动学习中起着重要作用。