Moghnieh Rima, Awad Lyn, Abdallah Dania, Jadayel Marwa, Sinno Loubna, Tamim Hani, Jisr Tamima, El-Hassan Salam, Lakkis Rawad, Dabbagh Rima, Bizri Abdul Rahman
Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases, Makassed General Hospital, Beirut, Lebanon.
Division of Infectious Diseases, Hôtel Dieu de France, Beirut, Lebanon.
J Chemother. 2020 Nov;32(7):368-384. doi: 10.1080/1120009X.2020.1755589. Epub 2020 May 2.
This study reports the effect of implementing an antibiotic stewardship program (ASP) based on the "handshake" strategy for 2 years on multiple endpoints compared with that in a preceding period when an antimicrobial restriction policy was only applied in the absence of a complete program in a tertiary-care Lebanese hospital. The studied endpoints were broad-spectrum antibiotic consumption, antibiotic expenditure, nosocomial bacteremia incidence rate, and patient outcome.An interrupted time series analysis was undertaken to assess the changes in the trend (ΔT) and level (ΔL) of the aforementioned endpoints among adult inpatients before (October 2013 to September 2015) and after the introduction of the ASP (October 2016 to September 2018).After the implementation of the "handshake" ASP, marked changes were observed in the consumption of broad-spectrum antibiotics. The mean use density levels for imipenem and meropenem decreased by 13.72% ( = 0.017), coupled with a decreasing rate of prescription (ΔT = -24.83 defined daily dose [DDD]/1,000 patient days [PD]/month; = 0.02). Tigecycline use significantly decreased in level by 69.19% ( < 0.0001) and in trend (ΔT = -25.63 DDD/1,000 PD/month; < 0.0001). A reduction in the use of colistin was also documented but did not reach statistical significance (ΔL = -8.71%, = 0.56; ΔT = -5.51 DDD/1,000 PD/month = -5.5; = 0.67). Antibiotic costs decreased by 24.6% after ASP implementation ( < 0.0001), and there was a distinct change from an increasing rate to a decreasing rate of expenditure (ΔT = -12.19 US dollars/PD/month; = 0.002). The incidence rate of nosocomial bacteremia caused by carbapenem-resistant gram-negative bacteria (CRGNB) decreased by 34.84% ( = 0.13) coupled with a decreasing trend (ΔT = -0.23 cases/1,000 PD/month, = 0.08). Specifically, a noticeable reduction in the incidence rate of bacteremia due to carbapenem-resistant was documented (ΔL = -54.34%, = 0.01; ΔT = -0.24 cases/1000 PD/month, = 0.01). Regarding patient outcome, all-cause mortality rates did not increase in level or in rate (ΔL = -3.55%, = 0.59; ΔT = -0.29 deaths/1000 PD/month, = 0.6). The length of stay and 7-day readmission rate remained stable between the two periods.In conclusion, the "handshake" ASP succeeded in controlling the prescription rates of antibiotics and in decreasing the nosocomial bacteremia rates caused by CRGNB without compromising patient outcome in our facility. It also had an economic effect in reducing antibiotic costs compared with the previous restriction policy on antimicrobial dispensing.
本研究报告了在黎巴嫩一家三级护理医院实施基于“握手”策略的抗生素管理计划(ASP)两年对多个终点指标的影响,并与之前仅实施抗菌药物限制政策(缺乏完整计划)的时期进行了比较。研究的终点指标包括广谱抗生素消耗量、抗生素支出、医院获得性菌血症发病率和患者结局。采用中断时间序列分析来评估在引入ASP之前(2013年10月至2015年9月)和之后(2016年10月至2018年9月)成年住院患者上述终点指标的趋势变化(ΔT)和水平变化(ΔL)。实施“握手”ASP后,观察到广谱抗生素的使用发生了显著变化。亚胺培南和美罗培南的平均使用密度水平下降了13.72%(P = 0.017),同时处方率下降(ΔT = -24.83限定日剂量[DDD]/1000患者日[PD]/月;P = 0.02)。替加环素的使用水平显著下降了69.19%(P < 0.0001),趋势也下降(ΔT = -25.63 DDD/1000 PD/月;P < 0.0001)。多粘菌素的使用也有减少,但未达到统计学意义(ΔL = -8.71%,P = 0.56;ΔT = -5.51 DDD/1000 PD/月 = -5.5;P = 0.67)。ASP实施后抗生素成本下降了24.6%(P < 0.0001),支出率从上升变为下降有明显变化(ΔT = -12.19美元/PD/月;P = 0.002)。耐碳青霉烯类革兰阴性菌(CRGNB)引起的医院获得性菌血症发病率下降了34.84%(P = 0.13),且有下降趋势(ΔT = -0.23例/1000 PD/月,P = 0.08)。具体而言,耐碳青霉烯类鲍曼不动杆菌引起的菌血症发病率有明显下降(ΔL = -54.34%,P = 0.01;ΔT = -0.24例/1000 PD/月,P = 0.01)。关于患者结局,全因死亡率在水平或率上均未增加(ΔL = -3.55%,P = 0.59;ΔT = -0.29例死亡/1000 PD/月,P = 0.6)。两个时期的住院时间和7天再入院率保持稳定。总之,“握手”ASP成功控制了抗生素的处方率,并降低了CRGNB引起的医院获得性菌血症发生率,且未影响我们医院患者的结局。与之前的抗菌药物配给限制政策相比,它在降低抗生素成本方面也有经济效果。