Specialized Tobacco Unit, Hospital Clínico San Carlos, Madrid, Spain.
Department of Economics, University Carlos III, Madrid, Spain.
Br J Surg. 2020 Jul;107(8):978-994. doi: 10.1002/bjs.11506. Epub 2020 May 5.
Smoking at the time of surgery is associated with postoperative complications. Quitting smoking before surgery is linked to fewer complications during the hospital stay. This work analysed whether a smoking cessation intervention before surgery is economically worthwhile when funded by the National Health System (NHS) in Spain.
The economic analysis considered costs and benefits of the intervention to the NHS for the year 2016. The population who would benefit comprised adult smokers who were ready to quit and for whom surgery requiring admission to hospital was planned. The intervention, a combination of medical counselling and use of a smoking cessation drug which should occur 12 weeks before surgery, considered one attempt only to quit smoking. Benefits were costs avoided by averting postoperative complications if cessation was successful. The analysis compared the net economic outcome (benefit minus cost of intervention) and the return on investment, for intervention funded by the NHS versus the current situation without funding.
Smoking cessation increased by 21·7 per cent with funding; the rate was 32·5 per cent when funded versus 10·7 per cent without funding, producing 9611 extra quitters. The cost per averted smoker was €1753 with a benefit of €503, achieving a net economic benefit of €4·8 million per year. Given the annual cost of the intervention (€17·4 million, of which €5·6 million (32·5 per cent) represents drugs), the return on investment was 28·7 per cent annually, equivalent to €1·29 per €1 of investment.
From the perspective of the Spanish NHS, the benefit of funding smoking cessation before surgery, in terms of healthcare cost savings, appears to greatly outweigh the costs.
手术时吸烟与术后并发症有关。术前戒烟与住院期间并发症减少有关。这项工作分析了在西班牙国家卫生系统(NHS)资助下,术前戒烟干预是否具有经济意义。
经济分析考虑了该干预措施对 NHS 在 2016 年的成本和收益。受益人群包括准备戒烟且计划接受需要住院手术的成年吸烟者。该干预措施是医疗咨询与使用戒烟药物的结合,应在手术前 12 周进行,只考虑一次戒烟尝试。如果成功戒烟,则避免术后并发症的成本将作为收益。该分析比较了 NHS 资助与不资助情况下的净经济结果(收益减去干预成本)和投资回报。
吸烟率增加了 21.7%;有资金资助时为 32.5%,无资金资助时为 10.7%,增加了 9611 名戒烟者。每避免一名吸烟者的成本为 1753 欧元,收益为 503 欧元,每年可获得 480 万欧元的净经济效益。考虑到干预措施的年度成本(1740 万欧元,其中 560 万欧元(32.5%)为药物),投资回报率为每年 28.7%,相当于每投资 1 欧元可获得 1.29 欧元。
从西班牙 NHS 的角度来看,在节省医疗保健成本方面,资助手术前戒烟的收益似乎大大超过了成本。