Department of General Surgery, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio; Cleveland Clinic Lerner College of Medicine of Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio.
Rwanda Military Hospital, Kigali, Rwanda.
J Surg Res. 2020 Sep;253:193-200. doi: 10.1016/j.jss.2020.03.057. Epub 2020 May 4.
Use of digital devices have become ubiquitous in healthcare and can create professionalism issues. This study presents opinions of faculty, residents, and medical students to inform policy on the appropriate use of digital devices in the patient care setting.
A survey was administered from September 2018 to October 2018 to faculty and residents within the general surgery department at a large academic medical center and all fourth-year medical students at an affiliated university. The survey included direct statements and case-based scenarios on similar themes to triangulate responses.
There were 114 participants in the survey-50 faculty, 26 residents, and 38 medical students. Digital device utilization was equivalent among all groups, and all participants use a smartphone. Digital devices were most frequently used during rounds and clinical conferences. Overall, digital device use was found more appropriate when seen in the case-based format rather than as a direct statement. Furthermore, use of these devices was seen as most appropriate when the provider explained its use or left the room to use the device.
Digital devices are used by faculty and trainees at similar rates for parallel purposes, and the benefits for patient-related care are evident. However, the use of digital devices in the presence of patients should be minimized and always preceded by an explanation. These findings can inform institutional policy when creating guidelines on the professional use of these devices in the patient care setting.
数字设备在医疗保健中的应用已经无处不在,可能会引发一些专业问题。本研究旨在收集教职员工、住院医师和医学生的意见,为制定患者护理环境中使用数字设备的相关政策提供参考。
本研究于 2018 年 9 月至 10 月期间,向一家大型学术医疗中心普外科的教职员工和住院医师,以及附属医院所有四年级医学生发放调查问卷。调查问卷中包含类似主题的直接陈述和基于案例的场景,以对回答进行三角验证。
共有 114 名参与者参与了调查,其中 50 名为教职员工,26 名为住院医师,38 名为医学生。所有参与者均使用智能手机,且在数字设备的使用上,这三个群体之间没有显著差异。在查房和临床会议期间,数字设备的使用最为频繁。总体而言,参与者认为数字设备的使用在基于案例的情况下比直接陈述更合适。此外,如果医生在使用设备前向患者解释或离开房间使用设备,他们认为这样的使用更为合适。
教职员工和住院医师以相似的频率出于类似的目的使用数字设备,且这些设备在患者护理中具有明显的益处。然而,应尽量减少在患者面前使用数字设备的情况,并在使用前向患者进行解释。这些发现可以为机构制定患者护理环境中使用这些设备的专业准则提供参考。