Division of Radiology, IEO European Institute of Oncology IRCCS, Via Giuseppe Ripamonti 435, 20141, Milan, Italy.
Paul Strickland Scanner Centre, Mount Vernon Cancer Centre, Rickmansworth Rd, Northwood, HA6 2RN, UK.
Cancer Imaging. 2020 May 11;20(1):34. doi: 10.1186/s40644-020-00315-0.
The number of studies describing the use of whole-body magnetic resonance imaging (WB-MRI) for screening of malignant tumours in asymptomatic subjects is increasing. Our aim is to review the methodologies used and the results of the published studies on per patient and per lesion analysis, and to provide recommendations on the use of WB-MRI for cancer screening.
We identified 12 studies, encompassing 6214 WB-MRI examinations, which provided the rates of abnormal findings and findings suspicious for cancer in asymptomatic subjects, from the general population. Eleven of 12 studies provided imaging protocols that included T1- and T2-weighted sequences, while only five included diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) of the whole body. Different categorical systems were used for the classification and the management of abnormal findings. Of 17,961 abnormal findings reported, 91% were benign, while 9% were oncologically relevant, requiring further investigations, and 0.5% of lesions were suspicious for cancer. A per-subject analysis showed that just 5% of subjects had no abnormal findings, while 95% had abnormal findings. Findings requiring further investigation were reported in 30% of all subjects, though in only 1.8% cancer was suspected. The overall rate of histologically confirmed cancer was 1.1%.
WB-MRI studies of cancer screening in the asymptomatic general population are too heterogeneous to draw impactful conclusions regarding efficacy. A 5-point lesion scale based on the oncological relevance of findings appears the most appropriate for risk-based management stratification. WB-MRI examinations should be reported by experienced oncological radiologists versed on WB-MRI reading abnormalities and on onward referral pathways.
描述全身磁共振成像(WB-MRI)用于无症状受试者恶性肿瘤筛查的研究数量正在增加。我们旨在回顾已发表的关于每位患者和每个病变分析的研究方法和结果,并就 WB-MRI 在癌症筛查中的应用提供建议。
我们确定了 12 项研究,涵盖了 6214 例 WB-MRI 检查,这些研究提供了来自普通人群的无症状受试者异常发现和疑似癌症的发现率。12 项研究中有 11 项提供了包括 T1 和 T2 加权序列的成像方案,而只有 5 项包括全身弥散加权成像(DWI)。不同的分类系统用于异常发现的分类和管理。在报告的 17961 项异常发现中,91%为良性,9%为肿瘤相关,需要进一步检查,0.5%的病变疑似癌症。对每位患者的分析显示,只有 5%的患者没有异常发现,而 95%的患者有异常发现。报告称,所有受试者中有 30%需要进一步调查,但只有 1.8%怀疑患有癌症。组织学确诊癌症的总发生率为 1.1%。
在无症状的普通人群中进行的癌症筛查的 WB-MRI 研究差异太大,无法就疗效得出有影响力的结论。一种基于发现的肿瘤相关性的 5 分病变量表似乎最适合基于风险的管理分层。WB-MRI 检查应由精通 WB-MRI 阅读异常和后续转诊途径的经验丰富的肿瘤放射科医生报告。