Xiang Zhenzhen, Zhang Jie, Zhao Jikai, Shao Jinchen, Zhao Lanxiang, Zhang Ye, Qin Gang, Xing Jie, Han Yuchen, Yu Keke
Department of Pathology, Shanghai Chest Hospital, Shanghai JiaoTong University, Shanghai 230000, China.
J Thorac Dis. 2020 Apr;12(4):1488-1495. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2020.02.34.
The accuracy of intraoperative pathological diagnosis of small-sized pulmonary nodules including ground-glass opacity (GGO) is important for the surgeon to choose a suitable surgical procedure. Diagnosis of the small-sized lesions of the lung by frozen section (FS) is very difficult for the pathologist because of limited FS technology. Here we tested an effective inflation treatment for FS to improve the diagnostic accuracy of small-sized lung lesions.
The lung specimens were derived from 113 patients who underwent the surgery at Shanghai Chest Hospital in 2018-2019. The specimens were randomly divided into two groups-uninflated or inflated with diluted embedding medium (Tissue-Tek OCT; Sakura Finetek-USA, CA). The qualities of the FSs were compared with that of corresponding permanent paraffin sections. The FS diagnoses were compared with the final pathologic diagnoses of corresponding permanent sections.
Our results showed that the quality of FS of lung tissue was excellent after inflation with diluted embedding medium (1:1). The total consistency between diagnosis of inflated FS and final pathological diagnosis was 85.7%. In control group, however, the consistency was only 70.2%. When the lesions were less than 1cm, the consistency between diagnosis of inflated FS and final pathological diagnosis was 90.3%, compared to 64.9% consistency in uninflated group (P=0.014, <0.05). When the lesions' computed tomography (CT) measurement threshold ≤-350 HU, the consistency between diagnosis of inflated FS and final pathological diagnosis was 88% compared to 73.2% consistency in uninflated group (P=0.071, >0.05). Accuracy, sensitivity and specificity were observed about 90% for adenocarcinoma (AIS), whereas it is drop to more than 80% for minimally invasive adenocarcinoma (MIA) in inflated FS.
Inflation with diluted embedding medium (1:1) could make lung tissue expand well during FS. By using this method, small-sized lesions (especially less than 1 cm) could be correctly diagnosed to enable adequate surgical procedure, and evaluation of which can be easily based on the intraoperative pathological diagnosis. The small lesions especially AIS could be readily identified on FS. Therefore, this method improves the diagnostic accuracy of FSs for small-sized lung lesions, and has important practical consequences for further therapy.
包括磨玻璃影(GGO)在内的小尺寸肺结节的术中病理诊断准确性对于外科医生选择合适的手术方式至关重要。由于冷冻切片(FS)技术有限,病理学家通过冷冻切片诊断肺部小病变非常困难。在此,我们测试了一种用于冷冻切片的有效膨胀处理方法,以提高小尺寸肺部病变的诊断准确性。
肺标本取自2018 - 2019年在上海胸科医院接受手术的113例患者。标本随机分为两组,一组不进行膨胀处理,另一组用稀释的包埋介质(Tissue-Tek OCT;美国樱花精技公司,加利福尼亚州)进行膨胀处理。将冷冻切片的质量与相应的永久性石蜡切片进行比较。将冷冻切片诊断结果与相应永久性切片的最终病理诊断结果进行比较。
我们的结果显示,用稀释的包埋介质(1:1)进行膨胀处理后,肺组织冷冻切片的质量极佳。膨胀处理后的冷冻切片诊断与最终病理诊断的总一致性为85.7%。然而,在对照组中一致性仅为70.2%。当病变小于1cm时,膨胀处理后的冷冻切片诊断与最终病理诊断的一致性为90.3%,而未膨胀组的一致性为64.9%(P = 0.014,<0.05)。当病变的计算机断层扫描(CT)测量阈值≤ - 350 HU时,膨胀处理后的冷冻切片诊断与最终病理诊断的一致性为88%,而未膨胀组的一致性为73.2%(P = 0.071,>0.05)。对于原位腺癌(AIS),冷冻切片的准确性、敏感性和特异性约为90%,而对于微浸润腺癌(MIA),膨胀处理后的冷冻切片中该数值降至80%以上。
用稀释的包埋介质(1:1)进行膨胀处理可使肺组织在冷冻切片过程中充分膨胀。通过使用这种方法,小尺寸病变(尤其是小于1cm的病变)能够得到正确诊断,从而能够进行适当的手术操作,并且可以很容易地根据术中病理诊断进行评估。小病变尤其是原位腺癌在冷冻切片上能够很容易地被识别。因此,这种方法提高了冷冻切片对小尺寸肺部病变的诊断准确性,对进一步治疗具有重要的实际意义。