Tam Jennifer, Tran Dat, Bettinger Julie A, Moore Dorothy, Sauvé Laura, Jadavji Taj, Tan Ben, Vaudry Wendy, Halperin Scott A, Top Karina A
Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Pediatrics, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada; Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Pediatrics, British Columbia Children's Hospital, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Pediatrics, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Vaccine. 2020 Jun 9;38(28):4457-4463. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.04.035. Epub 2020 May 12.
Neurological adverse events following immunization (AEFI) remain poorly characterized. Our objective was to describe pediatric acute and chronic encephalopathy and encephalitis cases following immunization reported via active sentinel surveillance from 1992 to 2012.
This case series provides a descriptive analysis of encephalopathy/encephalitis admissions reported to the Canadian Immunization Monitoring Program ACTive (IMPACT). Acute cases were reported if symptom onset (seizures, decreased level of consciousness, change in mental status) occurred 0-7 days after tetanus or pertussis-containing vaccines, 0-15 days after other inactivated vaccines, or 5-30 days after live vaccines. Chronic cases of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis or subacute progressive rubella encephalitis were reported at any interval after vaccination. Clinical data were examined to identify possible causes for encephalopathy/encephalitis other than vaccination.
Sixty-one cases of encephalopathy/encephalitis following immunization were reported to IMPACT over 21 years; 57 (93.4%) were classified as acute and 4 (6.6%) were chronic cases of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis. Most patients (73.8%) were previously healthy and immunocompetent. The vaccines most frequently administered prior to presentation were diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis, measles-mumps-rubella, and influenza. At discharge, 38 patients (62.3%) had normal neurological status or were expected to recover. Forty patients (70.2%) with acute encephalopathy/encephalitis had a more likely alternate etiology besides vaccination based on neuroimaging, symptoms suggestive of infection, laboratory-confirmed non-vaccine-related infection, or clinical diagnosis. No cases of encephalitis were causally associated with pertussis or influenza vaccines. Two patients (50%) with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis had known wild-type measles infection prior to immunization. Three deaths were reported during hospitalization (4.9%); all were acute encephalitis/encephalopathy cases and none were confirmed to be vaccine-related.
Encephalopathy/encephalitis following immunization remains a rare but serious adverse event. Most cases had another more likely etiology than vaccination. Continued monitoring and analysis of AEFI is paramount to ensure the safety of immunization programs.
免疫接种后发生的神经系统不良事件(AEFI)的特征仍不明确。我们的目的是描述1992年至2012年通过主动哨点监测报告的免疫接种后儿童急性和慢性脑病及脑炎病例。
本病例系列对向加拿大免疫监测计划主动监测(IMPACT)报告的脑病/脑炎住院病例进行了描述性分析。如果在接种含破伤风或百日咳疫苗后0至7天、接种其他灭活疫苗后0至15天或接种活疫苗后5至30天出现症状(癫痫发作、意识水平下降、精神状态改变),则报告为急性病例。亚急性硬化性全脑炎或亚急性进行性风疹脑炎的慢性病例在接种疫苗后的任何时间间隔报告。检查临床数据以确定除疫苗接种外可能导致脑病/脑炎的原因。
在21年期间,IMPACT共报告了61例免疫接种后发生的脑病/脑炎病例;57例(93.4%)被归类为急性病例,4例(6.6%)为亚急性硬化性全脑炎的慢性病例。大多数患者(73.8%)之前健康且免疫功能正常。发病前最常接种的疫苗是白喉-破伤风-百日咳疫苗、麻疹-腮腺炎-风疹疫苗和流感疫苗。出院时,38例患者(62.3%)神经状态正常或有望康复。根据神经影像学、提示感染的症状、实验室确诊的非疫苗相关感染或临床诊断,40例(70.2%)急性脑病/脑炎患者除疫苗接种外更可能有其他病因。没有脑炎病例与百日咳或流感疫苗有因果关系。2例(50%)亚急性硬化性全脑炎患者在免疫接种前已知有野生型麻疹感染。住院期间报告了3例死亡(4.9%);均为急性脑炎/脑病病例,且均未确诊与疫苗相关。
免疫接种后发生的脑病/脑炎仍然是一种罕见但严重的不良事件。大多数病例有比疫苗接种更可能的其他病因。持续监测和分析AEFI对于确保免疫计划的安全性至关重要。