School of Public Health, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
School of Exercise Science, Physical and Health Education, University of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.
J Nutr Educ Behav. 2020 Oct;52(10):935-943. doi: 10.1016/j.jneb.2020.03.009. Epub 2020 May 14.
To explore the impact of a capacity-building intervention (CBI) to support implementing provincial nutrition guidelines on food marketing in recreation facilities (RFs).
Randomized controlled trial within a natural experiment: food marketing in RFs from 3 guideline provinces randomly assigned to intervention (GL+CBI) or comparison (GL-ONLY) was compared with facilities in 1 province without guidelines (NO-GL). Food marketing was assessed by the Food and Beverage Marketing Assessment Tool for Settings.
Canadian provinces with/without voluntary nutrition guidelines for RFs.
51 RFs.
18-month CBI.
Change in Food and Beverage Marketing Assessment Tool for Settings scores and marketing features between baseline and follow-up across groups.
Kruskal-Wallis with post hoc Mann-Whitney U tests.
No significant differences in food marketing features between baseline and follow-up across groups except for a change in food marketing frequency (P = 0.045). The increase in frequency in NO-GL (median, 6.0; interquartile range, -2.0 to 8.5) was significantly greater than changes in the GL+CBI (P = 0.033) and GL-ONLY sites (P = 0.049).
Capacity-building was not associated with improved food marketing features potentially because of nonmandated nutrition guidelines, low priority for change, and vague or narrow facility goals and guidelines. Nutrition guidelines with specific unhealthy food marketing restrictions should be mandated and supported.
探讨一项能力建设干预措施(CBI)对支持实施省级营养指南对娱乐设施(RFs)中食品营销的影响。
自然实验中的随机对照试验:来自 3 个指南省的 RFs 中的食品营销随机分配到干预组(GL+CBI)或对照组(GL-ONLY),并与 1 个没有指南的省(NO-GL)的设施进行比较。使用环境食品和饮料营销评估工具评估食品营销。
有/没有 RFs 自愿营养指南的加拿大省份。
51 个 RFs。
18 个月的 CBI。
各组之间基线和随访之间食品和饮料营销评估工具得分和营销特征的变化。
Kruskal-Wallis 检验后进行 Mann-Whitney U 检验。
除了食品营销频率的变化(P=0.045)外,各组之间基线和随访之间的食品营销特征没有显著差异。NO-GL 中食品营销频率的增加(中位数,6.0;四分位距,-2.0 至 8.5)明显大于 GL+CBI(P=0.033)和 GL-ONLY 站点(P=0.049)的变化。
能力建设与改善食品营销特征无关,这可能是由于非强制性的营养指南、对变革的低优先级以及模糊或狭隘的设施目标和指南。应强制实施并支持具有具体不健康食品营销限制的营养指南。