Department of Health Promotion, CAPHRI Maastricht University, P.O. Box 616, 6200 MD, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
BMC Public Health. 2020 May 20;20(1):739. doi: 10.1186/s12889-020-08900-5.
As organ donation registration rates remain low, especially among lower-educated people, it is important to support this group in making their registration decision. To prepare lower-educated students in the Netherlands for making a well-informed decision, an interactive educational program was developed. We aim to understand both the (quality of) implementation as well as to contextualize the effects of this program in a lower-educated school setting.
The process evaluation was part of a Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial, in which 11 schools for Intermediate Vocational Education throughout the Netherlands participated. Teachers who taught a course on Citizenship delivered three intervention elements (i.e. video fragments and discussion, quizzes with tailored feedback and an exercise filling out a registration form) to their students. Implementation was assessed by interviews with teachers, questionnaires from students, logbooks from teachers and user data from Google Analytics.
The program was well received and implemented, but on-the-spot adaptations were made by teachers to fit their students better. Within the lower-educated target group, differences between students are high in terms of active participation, reading abilities, knowledge and attention span. The program fit well within their regular teaching activities, but the topic of organ donation is not always prioritized by teachers.
We see opportunities to disseminate the program on a larger scale and reach a group that has been neglected in organ donation education before. Within the program, there are possibilities to increase the effectiveness of the program, such as alternative delivery methods for the elements with a lot of text, the addition of booster sessions and guidelines for teachers to adapt the program to students of different levels within Intermediate Vocational Education. Moreover, in order to have an impact on a national level, strategies need to be employed to reach high numbers of students and, therefore, support on a higher level is needed (both within schools and at policy level).
Dutch Trial Register, NTR6771. Prospectively registered on 24 October 2017.
由于器官捐赠登记率仍然较低,尤其是在受教育程度较低的人群中,因此支持这一群体做出登记决定非常重要。为了让荷兰的低学历学生做好知情决策,我们开发了一个互动式教育项目。我们旨在了解该项目的(质量)实施情况,并将其在低学历学校环境中的效果进行背景化分析。
该过程评估是一项集群随机对照试验的一部分,荷兰共有 11 所中等职业教育学校参与了该试验。教授公民学课程的教师向学生教授三个干预元素(即视频片段和讨论、带有针对性反馈的测验、以及填写登记表格的练习)。通过教师访谈、学生问卷调查、教师日志和 Google Analytics 的用户数据来评估实施情况。
该项目受到了欢迎并得到了实施,但教师根据学生的实际情况进行了现场调整。在低学历目标群体中,学生在积极参与度、阅读能力、知识和注意力持续时间方面存在较大差异。该项目很好地融入了他们的常规教学活动,但器官捐赠的话题并不总是被教师优先考虑。
我们看到了在更大范围内传播该项目的机会,可以接触到之前在器官捐赠教育中被忽视的群体。在该项目中,有一些可能性可以提高项目的效果,例如为文本较多的元素提供替代的交付方式、增加强化课程以及为教师提供适应不同中级职业教育学生水平的方案指南。此外,为了在国家层面上产生影响,需要采用策略来覆盖大量的学生,因此需要在学校和政策层面上提供更多的支持。
荷兰试验注册处,NTR6771. 2017 年 10 月 24 日前瞻性注册。