Jose Kim, MacDonald Fiona, Vandenberg Miriam, Williams Julie, Abbott-Chapman Joan, Venn Alison, Smith Kylie J
University of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia.
Victoria University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Health Educ Behav. 2020 Aug;47(4):619-630. doi: 10.1177/1090198120920193. Epub 2020 May 31.
Many Australian primary schools have established school breakfast clubs (SBCs) to address concerns about children arriving at school hungry and the subsequent impact on learning but their effectiveness is uncertain. This study aimed to identify the perceived benefits, impacts, operational practices, and challenges of running SBCs. Case studies with 10 Australian primary schools from different socioeconomic and geographic areas. Focus groups or interviews were held with 142 participants including students, parents/carers, school staff, and funding body representatives between July 2016 and October 2017. There were no eligibility criteria to attend SBCs with all students able to attend, regardless of household income. Thus, participating in the SBC was often reported as a matter of choice rather than a consequence of food insecurity. Participants, including children, discussed the many social benefits of SBCs (i.e., social eating, relationship building, school connection, and engagement) as well as perceived improved classroom behavior. Challenges for program delivery included resource limitations, particularly, the reliance on volunteers and sourcing food. SBCs offered a range of benefits beyond their primary goal of addressing food security. SBCs were highly valued by members of the school community for their social, welfare, well-being, and educational benefits, but program sustainability is constrained by resource limitations.
许多澳大利亚小学设立了学校早餐俱乐部(SBC),以解决人们对儿童饿着肚子上学及其对学习产生的后续影响的担忧,但其效果尚不确定。本研究旨在确定运营SBC的感知益处、影响、操作实践和挑战。对来自不同社会经济和地理区域的10所澳大利亚小学进行了案例研究。在2016年7月至2017年10月期间,与142名参与者进行了焦点小组讨论或访谈,参与者包括学生、家长/照顾者、学校工作人员和资助机构代表。参加SBC没有资格标准,所有学生无论家庭收入如何都可以参加。因此,参与SBC通常被视为一种选择,而非粮食不安全的结果。包括儿童在内的参与者讨论了SBC的诸多社会效益(即社交用餐、建立关系、与学校建立联系和参与度)以及课堂行为的改善。项目实施面临的挑战包括资源限制,尤其是依赖志愿者和获取食物。SBC除了解决粮食安全这一主要目标外,还带来了一系列益处。学校社区成员高度重视SBC的社会、福利、幸福和教育效益,但项目的可持续性受到资源限制的制约。