Edward N. Okeke (
Zachary Wagner is an associate policy researcher in the Department of Economics, Sociology, and Statistics, RAND Corporation, in Santa Monica, California.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2020 Jun;39(6):1051-1059. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2019.00893.
Ninety-nine percent of global maternal deaths occur in low- and middle-income countries. The high mortality rates are often attributed to a large portion of births occurring outside of formal health care facilities. This has prompted the creation of programs to promote the use of formal delivery care. However, poor-quality care in health facilities in low- and middle-income countries is well documented. It is not clear that shifting births into health facilities in these settings necessarily leads to better-quality care. We present results from a randomized controlled trial in Nigeria that evaluated a conditional cash transfer intervention that paid pregnant women to deliver in a health facility. We found that the intervention led to a 41 percent increase in facility deliveries. We also found improvements in the quality of delivery care (as a result of more births taking place in formal health care settings) and in overall satisfaction with care. We found no evidence of a reduction in preventable complications that led to maternal deaths, though we found some improvements in self-reported health. Our results indicate that promoting facility deliveries can improve the quality of care received, even in settings where formal care quality is poor. However, modest quality improvements might not be sufficient to substantially improve health outcomes.
全球 99%的孕产妇死亡发生在中低收入国家。高死亡率通常归因于很大一部分分娩发生在正规医疗保健机构之外。这促使人们创建了促进正规分娩护理的项目。然而,中低收入国家卫生机构的低质量护理是有据可查的。在这些环境中,将分娩转移到医疗机构是否必然会带来更好的护理质量尚不清楚。我们展示了尼日利亚一项随机对照试验的结果,该试验评估了一项有条件现金转移干预措施,该措施向在医疗机构分娩的孕妇支付报酬。我们发现,该干预措施使医疗机构分娩的比例增加了 41%。我们还发现,分娩护理的质量有所提高(由于更多的分娩发生在正规的医疗保健环境中),对护理的总体满意度也有所提高。我们没有发现可预防的并发症导致孕产妇死亡的减少的证据,尽管我们发现一些自我报告的健康状况有所改善。我们的研究结果表明,促进医疗机构分娩可以提高所接受的护理质量,即使在正规护理质量较差的环境中也是如此。然而,适度的质量改进可能不足以显著改善健康结果。