Behaeghe Olivia, Van Beeck Annelies, Dossche Lieven, Somville Johan
Acta Orthop Belg. 2020 Mar;86(1):17-21.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the inter- and intraobserver reliability of a CT-based femoral anteversion measurement. 17 CT scans showing an abnormal anteversion on one side were presented to 6. Three measurements of all scans were obtained : two bilateral measurements and a third measurement with a flipped CT scan. Interobserver correlation results using the spearman test for left, right and anteversion difference had a mean of respectively : 0.918, 0.760 and 0.757. Intraobserver correlation had a maximum of respectively : 0,99, 0,89 and 0,94. Correlation coefficients were consistently higher for the second measurement. The lower correlation boarder of 0,8 was often exceeded. Intraobserver correlation was higher than interobserver correlation. As we evaluated a high variance in interobserver reliability, we recommend an accurate and objective measurement of the anteversion angle. A personal measurement and comparison to the radiological protocol is necessary.
本研究的目的是评估基于CT的股骨前倾角测量在观察者间和观察者内的可靠性。向6名观察者展示了17例一侧前倾角异常的CT扫描图像。对所有扫描图像进行了三次测量:两次双侧测量和一次翻转CT扫描测量。使用Spearman检验得出的观察者间相关性结果,左侧、右侧和前倾角差异的平均值分别为:0.918、0.760和0.757。观察者内相关性的最大值分别为:0.99、0.89和0.94。第二次测量的相关系数始终较高。经常超过0.8的较低相关边界。观察者内相关性高于观察者间相关性。由于我们评估了观察者间可靠性的高变异性,我们建议对前倾角进行准确客观的测量。需要进行个人测量并与放射学方案进行比较。