Rwanda Agriculture and Animal Resources Development Board, P.O; Box 5016, Kigali, Rwanda.
Department of Animal Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture, Egerton University, P.O; Box 536, Egerton, Kenya.
BMC Vet Res. 2020 Jun 5;16(1):175. doi: 10.1186/s12917-020-02368-6.
Endometritis is a prevalent uterine disease in postpartum cows. The disease reduces fertility performance and milk yield, and subsequently, productivity and profitability of dairy farms. The reduction in performance is associated with considerable economic losses on dairy farms. Smallholder farmers are likely to incur considerable economic losses from the disease where they lack knowledge of effective prevention and control measures for the disease. This study used farmer's perspectives to determine the effectiveness of different management interventions (MIs) for endometritis prevention and control on smallholder farms in Rwanda practicing dairy zero-grazing. The best-worst scaling (BWS) choice method was applied that relied on past 1 year recall data obtained from 154 farmers. These farmers were identified through snowball sampling in a cross-sectional study.
Of the 20 MIs evaluated, 12 scored highly for effectiveness. The top four most effective are: avoiding sharing equipment with neighbouring farms (45.5%), consulting animal health service provider about disease treatment (31.8%), keeping cows in a clean and dry shed (26.7%), and selecting sires based on calving ease (26.6%). The MIs considered least effective were: maintaining clean transition cow housing (35.1%), removal of fetal membrane immediately after passing (33.1%), disinfecting the equipment used in calving assistance before and after use (32.5%), and selecting sires with low percent stillbirths (29.2%).
This study has demonstrated the application of BWS object case method in understanding the MIs that farmers consider are most effective in the prevention and control of endometritis disease in the dairy herds. The MIs are on-farm biosecurity and hygiene, seeking veterinary services for disease treatment and selecting sires for ease of calving. These MIs should be considered for prioritization in extension services and research to continuously improve and enhance their practical application on smallholder dairy farms.
子宫内膜炎是产后奶牛常见的子宫疾病。该疾病降低了奶牛的繁殖性能和产奶量,进而降低了奶牛场的生产力和盈利能力。这种性能下降与奶牛场的巨大经济损失有关。小规模养殖户由于缺乏有效的疾病预防和控制措施,可能会遭受巨大的经济损失。本研究采用农民的观点来确定不同管理干预措施(MI)对卢旺达实行奶牛零放牧的小规模养殖场子宫内膜炎预防和控制的有效性。应用了最佳最差缩放(BWS)选择方法,该方法依赖于从 154 名农民获得的过去 1 年回忆数据。这些农民是通过在横断面研究中进行雪球抽样确定的。
在所评估的 20 项 MI 中,有 12 项具有较高的有效性。前四项最有效的是:避免与邻近农场共享设备(45.5%)、就疾病治疗咨询动物健康服务提供商(31.8%)、将奶牛饲养在清洁干燥的畜舍中(26.7%)以及根据难产选择公牛(26.6%)。认为最无效的 MI 是:保持过渡奶牛畜舍清洁(35.1%)、分娩后立即清除胎膜(33.1%)、在使用前后对用于助产的设备进行消毒(32.5%)以及选择低死胎率的公牛(29.2%)。
本研究展示了 BWS 对象案例方法在理解农民认为最有效的预防和控制奶牛子宫内膜炎疾病的 MI 中的应用。这些 MI 是农场生物安全和卫生、为疾病治疗寻求兽医服务以及选择易于分娩的公牛。这些 MI 应在推广服务和研究中优先考虑,以不断改进和加强其在小规模奶牛场的实际应用。