Neurosurgery, S. Anna University Hospital, Ferrara, Italy; Department of Morphology, Anatomy and Experimental Medicine, University of Ferrara, Italy.
Neurosurgery, S. Anna University Hospital, Ferrara, Italy.
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2020 Sep;196:105911. doi: 10.1016/j.clineuro.2020.105911. Epub 2020 Jun 4.
Recently, social media showed musicians performing pieces during awake surgery for brain diseases, such as tumors or dystonia. They tend to emphasize the use of intraoperative performance. Our aim is to review the literature on intraoperative performance in awake surgery for musicians, in order to understand if it is appropriate for all kind of procedures reported. We performed a comprehensive review of the literature with chosen keywords. We selected all papers regarding musicians who underwent awake surgery. The data extracted were analyzed. Literature search retrieved a total of 12 studies: among these, 5 studies reported musicians performing pieces during surgery. Google search returned a total of 11 cases. The ability to play an instrument involves multiple higher cognitive functions that remain not fully understood. During tumor resection or surgical treatment for epilepsies involving eloquent areas in musicians, an intraoperative musical performance could allow a more accurate monitoring of complex function, rather than the simple finger exercises and movements. On the other hand, treatment of dystonia follows standardized stereotactic procedures (DBS), the target is preset and determined by imaging and neurophysiology. The patient indeed, is awake mainly for side effects monitoring. However, in most cases, playing music did not improve or modify surgery. Intraoperative performances certainly generate amazement and interest, especially in the media and in non-experts. During tumor or brain lesion resection, intraoperative musical performances can avoid subsequent neurological al disturbances. However, in several procedures (DBS), playing music did not improve or modify surgery.
最近,社交媒体上展示了音乐家在脑部疾病(如肿瘤或肌张力障碍)的清醒手术中进行演奏的情况。他们倾向于强调术中表演的使用。我们的目的是回顾关于音乐家在清醒手术中进行术中表演的文献,以了解它是否适用于所有报道的手术类型。我们使用选定的关键词对文献进行了全面回顾。我们选择了所有关于接受清醒手术的音乐家的论文。提取的数据进行了分析。文献检索共检索到 12 项研究:其中 5 项研究报告了音乐家在手术过程中演奏乐曲。谷歌搜索共返回了 11 个案例。演奏乐器的能力涉及到多种尚未完全理解的高级认知功能。在肿瘤切除或涉及音乐家语言区的癫痫手术治疗中,术中音乐表演可以更准确地监测复杂功能,而不是简单的手指练习和运动。另一方面,肌张力障碍的治疗遵循标准化的立体定向手术(DBS),目标是通过影像学和神经生理学预先设定和确定。患者确实是为了监测副作用而保持清醒。然而,在大多数情况下,演奏音乐并没有改善或改变手术。术中表演确实会引起惊讶和兴趣,尤其是在媒体和非专业人士中。在肿瘤或脑损伤切除过程中,术中音乐表演可以避免随后的神经功能紊乱。然而,在一些手术(DBS)中,演奏音乐并没有改善或改变手术。