Kenigsberg Alexander P, Khouri Roger K, Kuprasertkul Amy, Wong Daniel, Ganesan Vishnu, Lemack Gary E
Department of Urology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX.
Department of Urology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX.
Urology. 2020 Sep;143:55-61. doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2020.05.072. Epub 2020 Jun 17.
To evaluate urology applicants' opinions about the interview process during the COVID-19 pandemic.
An anonymous survey was emailed to applicants to our institution from the 2019 and 2020 urology matches prior to issuance of professional organization guidelines. The survey inquired about attitudes toward the residency interview process in the era of COVID-19 and which interview elements could be replicated virtually. Descriptive statistics were utilized.
Eighty percent of urology applicants from the 2019 and 2020 matches received our survey. One hundred fifty-six people (24% of recipients) responded. Thirty-four percent preferred virtual interviews, while 41% in-person interviews at each program, and 25% regional/centralized interviews. Sixty-four percent said that interactions with residents (pre/postinterview social and informal time) were the most important interview day component and 81% said it could not be replicated virtually. Conversely, 81% believed faculty interviews could be replicated virtually. Eighty-seven percent believed that city visits could not be accomplished virtually. A plurality felt that away rotations and second-looks should be allowed (both 45%).
Applicants feel that faculty interviews can be replicated virtually, while resident interactions cannot. Steps such as a low-stakes second looks after programs submit rank lists (potentially extending this window) and small virtual encounters with residents could ease applicant concerns.
Applicants have concerns about changes to the match processes. Programs can adopt virtual best practices to address these issues.
评估泌尿外科住院医师职位申请者对COVID-19大流行期间面试过程的看法。
在专业组织发布指南之前,通过电子邮件向参加2019年和2020年泌尿外科住院医师职位匹配的本校申请者发送了一份匿名调查问卷。该调查询问了他们对COVID-19时代住院医师面试过程的态度,以及哪些面试环节可以通过虚拟方式进行。采用描述性统计方法。
参加2019年和2020年匹配的泌尿外科申请者中有80%收到了我们的调查问卷。156人(占收件人的24%)回复了问卷。34%的人倾向于虚拟面试,41%的人希望每个项目进行现场面试,25%的人倾向于地区性/集中式面试。64%的人表示,与住院医师的互动(面试前/后的社交和非正式时间)是面试当天最重要的环节,81%的人表示无法通过虚拟方式复制这一环节。相反,81%的人认为教员面试可以通过虚拟方式进行。87%的人认为无法通过虚拟方式完成城市参观。大多数人认为应该允许远程轮转和二次参观(均为45%)。
申请者认为教员面试可以通过虚拟方式进行,而与住院医师的互动则不能。在项目提交排名名单后进行低风险的二次参观(可能延长这个窗口期)以及与住院医师进行小型虚拟交流等措施,可以缓解申请者的担忧。
申请者对匹配过程的变化感到担忧。各项目可以采用虚拟方式的最佳做法来解决这些问题。