Department of Urology, New York Medical College, Westchester Medical Center, Valhalla, NY.
Department of Urology, New York Medical College, Westchester Medical Center, Valhalla, NY.
Urology. 2021 Nov;157:44-50. doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2021.05.079. Epub 2021 Jul 17.
To assess interviewing applicant perceptions of a virtual urology residency interview in the setting of changes mandated by COVID-19 and to determine applicant preference for virtual or in person interviews. Applicant perceptions of multiple interview components were queried to identify program specific and interview modality specific strengths or weaknesses in the 2020 to 2021 Urology Match.
A 12 question multiple choice and free text survey was emailed to 66 virtually interviewed applicants for open residency positions at a metropolitan training program after conclusion of interviews. Items of interest included interview type preference, overall interview impression, and recommendations for improvement.
A total of 50 of 66 (76%) applicants completed the survey corresponding to approximately 11% of the 2020 national urology applicant pool. A total of 49 of 50 (96%) respondents assessed faculty interaction and the virtual platform positively. A total of 38 of 50 (76%) was satisfied with their resident interaction and 32 of 50 (64%) applicants stated they were able to satisfactorily evaluate the site and program. Ultimately, 39 of 50 (78%) respondents would have preferred an in person interview to our virtual interview. Respondents cited challenges in assessing program culture and program physical site virtually.
The majority of survey respondents indicated a preference for in person interviews. A smaller proportion of applicants preferred virtual interviews citing their convenience and lower cost. Efforts to improve the virtual interview experience may focus on improving applicant-resident interaction and remote site assessment.
评估申请人对虚拟泌尿科住院医师面试的看法,了解申请人对虚拟或面对面面试的偏好,以了解在 COVID-19 要求的变化背景下,申请人对虚拟面试的看法。调查了申请人对多种面试环节的看法,以确定 2020-2021 年泌尿科匹配中各项目的具体优势和不足以及面试模式的具体优势和不足。
在面试结束后,向参加大都市培训项目开放住院医师职位的 66 名虚拟面试申请人发送了一份 12 个多项选择题和自由文本调查。感兴趣的项目包括面试类型偏好、整体面试印象以及改进建议。
共有 50 名申请人(76%)完成了调查,约占全国 2020 年泌尿科申请人总数的 11%。共有 49 名申请人(96%)对教师互动和虚拟平台给予了积极评价。共有 38 名申请人(76%)对他们与住院医师的互动感到满意,32 名申请人(64%)表示他们能够满意地评估该地点和项目。最终,50 名申请人中的 39 名(78%)表示,他们更愿意参加面对面的面试,而不是我们的虚拟面试。受访者表示,在虚拟评估中存在评估项目文化和项目物理场地的挑战。
大多数调查受访者表示更喜欢面对面的面试。少数申请人更喜欢虚拟面试,认为这种面试更方便、成本更低。为改善虚拟面试体验而做出的努力可能集中在改善申请人与住院医师的互动以及远程站点评估上。