Bonadonna G, Rossi A, Valagussa P, Banfi A, Veronesi U
Cancer. 1977 Jun;39(6 Suppl):2904-15. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(197706)39:6<2904::aid-cncr2820390677>3.0.co;2-8.
In a prospective randomized study adjuvant combination chemotherapy with CMF was administered for 12 monthly cycles to 207 patients subjected to radical mastectomy (Halsted or extended) and treatment failure was compared to that observed in 179 patients whose primary therapy consisted only of radical surgery (control group). All patients of both groups had histologically positive axillary lymph nodes. At three years from mastectomy the total failure time distribution was 45.7% in control patients compared to 26.3% in women given CMF (P less than 0.0001). New disease manifestations were higher in the subgroup with four or more nodes (64.9% vs 41.5%) compared to that with one to three nodes (37.9% vs 19.1%). Premenopausal controls showed a progressively higher incidence of treatment failure compared to CMF patients (P=0.00001). The decreased recurrence rate in postmenopausal women given CMF was appreciable only during the first 12 months. From this time on, the difference no longer existed. The cumulative percent of recurrence in patients without or with drug-induced amenorrhea (27.2% vs 9.2%) was not statistically significant. At three years 21.4% of control patients have died of progressive cancer compared to 10.4% of CMF patients. The difference in the survival curves was not significant (P=0.08). Toxicity was moderate and reversible. No drug induced neoplasm was observed. Present results confirm the efficacy of 12 CMF cycles in premenopausal patients. Postmenopausal women probably require a more intensive and prolonged adjuvant chemotherapy.
在一项前瞻性随机研究中,对207例行根治性乳房切除术(Halsted术式或扩大根治术)的患者进行了为期12个周期的CMF辅助联合化疗,并将治疗失败情况与179例仅接受根治性手术的患者(对照组)进行了比较。两组所有患者的腋窝淋巴结组织学检查均为阳性。乳房切除术后三年,对照组患者的总失败时间分布为45.7%,而接受CMF治疗的女性为26.3%(P<0.0001)。有四个或更多淋巴结的亚组中出现新疾病表现的比例(64.9%对41.5%)高于有一至三个淋巴结的亚组(37.9%对19.1%)。绝经前对照组患者的治疗失败发生率逐渐高于接受CMF治疗的患者(P=0.00001)。接受CMF治疗的绝经后女性复发率降低仅在最初12个月较为明显。从那时起,差异不再存在。无药物性闭经或有药物性闭经患者的复发累积百分比(27.2%对9.2%)无统计学意义。三年时,21.4%的对照组患者死于进展期癌症,而接受CMF治疗的患者为10.4%。生存曲线差异不显著(P=0.08)。毒性为中度且可逆。未观察到药物诱导的肿瘤。目前的结果证实了12个周期CMF方案对绝经前患者的疗效。绝经后女性可能需要更强化和更长时间的辅助化疗。