Departments of Biomedical Engineering and Statistics, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois.
Neurobionics Lab, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
J Appl Physiol (1985). 2020 Sep 1;129(3):483-491. doi: 10.1152/japplphysiol.00133.2020. Epub 2020 Jul 9.
Joint stiffness is often measured to make inferences about the stiffness of muscle groups, but little can be gleaned about individual muscles. Decomposing the muscular origins of joint stiffness may inform treatment targets for conditions like spasticity. To complement joint stiffness, shear wave ultrasound elastography has been used to estimate the material properties of individual muscles. If shear wave measures are to be used to assess the muscular origins of joint stiffness, then changes in shear wave velocity should strongly relate to changes in joint stiffness. Here, we estimated the relationships between shear wave velocity in the primary plantar flexors [soleus (SOL) and medial gastrocnemius (MG)] and ankle joint stiffness. Participants performed isometric plantar flexion tasks at a range of activations (0-40%), while joint stiffness and muscle shear wave velocities were obtained. We observed a strong, linear relationship between plantar flexor shear wave velocities and joint stiffness. Remarkably, the parameter estimates of this stiffness-shear wave relationship strongly agreed with theoretical and literature-based estimates [SOL:MG parameter ratios = 2.83 (observed) vs. 2.85 (expected from theoretical stiffness ratio)]. Finally, a musculoskeletal model of the plantar flexors was able to accurately reproduce joint stiffness estimates, and shear wave velocities could explain 80-95% of the variance in modeled muscle stiffness. These findings suggest that shear wave velocity may be used to infer the muscular origins of changes in joint stiffness. Shear wave velocity is commonly assessed to infer the muscular origins of changes in joint stiffness, but the exact relationship between shear wave velocity changes in muscle and joint stiffness changes remains unknown. Here, we systematically evaluated and quantified this relationship in the plantar flexors. Our results provide evidence for the ability of shear wave velocity to elucidate the muscular origins of joint stiffness changes.
关节僵硬通常用于推断肌肉群的僵硬程度,但对于单个肌肉却知之甚少。分解关节僵硬的肌肉起源可以为痉挛等疾病的治疗靶点提供信息。为了补充关节僵硬,剪切波超声弹性成像已被用于估计单个肌肉的材料特性。如果要使用剪切波测量来评估关节僵硬的肌肉起源,那么剪切波速度的变化应该与关节僵硬的变化密切相关。在这里,我们估计了主要跖屈肌[比目鱼肌(SOL)和内侧腓肠肌(MG)]的剪切波速度与踝关节僵硬之间的关系。参与者在一系列激活水平(0-40%)下进行等长跖屈运动,同时获得关节僵硬和肌肉剪切波速度。我们观察到跖屈肌剪切波速度与关节僵硬之间存在很强的线性关系。值得注意的是,这种僵硬-剪切波关系的参数估计与理论和基于文献的估计强烈一致[SOL:MG 参数比=2.83(观察到)与 2.85(理论刚度比预期)]。最后,一个跖屈肌的肌肉骨骼模型能够准确地再现关节刚度估计,并且剪切波速度可以解释模型化肌肉刚度变化的 80-95%。这些发现表明,剪切波速度可以用于推断关节刚度变化的肌肉起源。剪切波速度常用于推断关节刚度变化的肌肉起源,但剪切波速度在肌肉和关节刚度变化之间的关系尚不清楚。在这里,我们系统地评估和量化了跖屈肌中的这种关系。我们的结果为剪切波速度阐明关节僵硬变化的肌肉起源的能力提供了证据。