Kline Alexander C, Feeny Norah C, Zoellner Lori A
PTSD Treatment and Research Program, Case Western Reserve University, Department of Psychological Sciences, 11220 Bellflower Road, Cleveland, OH, 44106-7123, USA.
PTSD Treatment and Research Program, Case Western Reserve University, Department of Psychological Sciences, 11220 Bellflower Road, Cleveland, OH, 44106-7123, USA.
Behav Res Ther. 2020 Sep;132:103690. doi: 10.1016/j.brat.2020.103690. Epub 2020 Jun 29.
The efficacy of treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) among African Americans is less clear given underrepresentation in clinical research. Additionally, intervention research examining race has typically not considered within-group heterogeneity, such as acculturation, ethnic identity, and cultural attitudes. In a randomized controlled trial, African American (n = 43) and Caucasian (n = 130) individuals received prolonged exposure (PE) or sertraline for PTSD, comparing: treatment response, retention, and treatment beliefs and preferences. Indirect effects of cultural variables were also examined. African Americans reported stronger ethnic identity (d = 0.71), less positive attitudes toward other groups (d = 0.36), and less acculturation (d = 0.51) than Caucasians. Noninferiority analyses indicated clinically equivalent PTSD outcomes for African Americans and Caucasians in both treatments. Groups showed comparable improvements in depression and functioning, and similar treatment preferences and beliefs. African Americans attended fewer sessions in PE (d = 0.87) and sertraline (d = 0.53) than Caucasians. Indirect effects analyses indicated positive cultural attitudes toward other ethnoracial groups were consistently associated with better treatment outcome and retention. Despite no differential effectiveness, findings may highlight the need to target retention among African Americans. Within-group cultural aspects of race may be an informative complement to basic, categorical conceptualizations.
鉴于非裔美国人在临床研究中的代表性不足,创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)治疗方法对他们的疗效尚不清楚。此外,研究种族因素的干预研究通常没有考虑群体内部的异质性,如文化适应、种族认同和文化态度。在一项随机对照试验中,非裔美国人(n = 43)和白人(n = 130)个体接受了针对PTSD的延长暴露疗法(PE)或舍曲林治疗,比较了治疗反应、留存率以及治疗信念和偏好。还研究了文化变量的间接影响。与白人相比,非裔美国人报告出更强的种族认同(d = 0.71)、对其他群体较不积极的态度(d = 0.36)以及较低的文化适应程度(d = 0.51)。非劣效性分析表明,两种治疗方法中,非裔美国人和白人的PTSD临床结局相当。两组在抑郁和功能改善方面表现相当,治疗偏好和信念也相似。与白人相比,非裔美国人参加PE治疗(d = 0.87)和舍曲林治疗(d = 0.53)的疗程较少。间接效应分析表明,对其他种族群体持积极的文化态度与更好的治疗结局和留存率始终相关。尽管没有差异有效性,但研究结果可能凸显了针对非裔美国人留存率的必要性。种族的群体内部文化因素可能是对基本分类概念的有益补充。