Blanco Portillo A, García-Caballero R, Real de Asúa D, Herreros B
Unidad de Medicina Interna, Hospital Universitario Fundación Alcorcón, Alcorcón, Madrid, España.
Servicio de Medicina Interna, Hospital Universitario Infanta Sofía, San Sebastián de los Reyes, Madrid, España; Grupo de Trabajo de Bioética y Profesionalismo, Sociedad Española de Medicina Interna , Madrid, España.
Rev Clin Esp. 2020 Jul 7. doi: 10.1016/j.rce.2020.05.011.
Clinicians face a multitude of ethical conflicts in their daily practice. There have been no studies on the types of ethical conflicts encountered most frequently and that are of most concern to clinicians in Spain. The aim of this study is to report the most common ethical conflicts faced by Spanish internists, as well as the importance that the practitioners attribute to each conflict.
Our observational cross-sectional study employed a voluntary and anonymous survey aimed at Spanish medical internists and distributed through an ad hoc platform of the Spanish Society of Internal Medicine.
The most common and relevant ethical issues for Spanish internists are related to patients' end of life (decisions limiting therapeutic effort, use of palliative treatments, the establishment of do-not-resuscitate orders), the conflicts arising within the doctor-patient/family relationship, and making decisions with noncompetent patients. These results are similar to those of other English and European series. The ethical problems further complicate the healthcare activity of clinicians who more often notice these problems (50.3%) than those who do not notice them (16%).
The most common and relevant ethical conflicts among Spanish internists are related to managing patients' end of life, followed by those related to the doctor-patient relationship and the management of noncompetent patients. It is essential that training programs be designed to better address and recognise these problems.
临床医生在日常工作中面临众多伦理冲突。西班牙尚未有关于临床医生最常遇到且最关注的伦理冲突类型的研究。本研究旨在报告西班牙内科医生面临的最常见伦理冲突,以及从业者对每种冲突的重视程度。
我们的观察性横断面研究采用了一项针对西班牙内科实习医生的自愿且匿名的调查,并通过西班牙内科医学会的一个专门平台进行分发。
西班牙内科医生最常见且相关的伦理问题与患者的临终情况(限制治疗力度的决策、姑息治疗的使用、制定不要复苏医嘱)、医患/家庭关系中产生的冲突以及对无行为能力患者的决策有关。这些结果与其他英文和欧洲系列研究的结果相似。伦理问题使临床医生的医疗活动更加复杂,更多临床医生(50.3%)比未注意到这些问题的医生(16%)更常注意到这些问题。
西班牙内科医生中最常见且相关的伦理冲突与处理患者的临终情况有关,其次是与医患关系以及对无行为能力患者的管理有关。必须设计培训项目以更好地应对和认识这些问题。