Rusley Jack, Tomaszewski Kathy, Kim Julia, Robinson Larnce, Rose Kadi-Ann, Aronin Caroline, Molloy Matthew, Arrington-Sanders Renata
Division of General Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Md.
Pediatr Qual Saf. 2020 May 18;5(3):e282. doi: 10.1097/pq9.0000000000000282. eCollection 2020 May-Jun.
The transition from pediatric to adult care is under-studied in primary care. Electronic health record-integrated transition planning tools (ETPTs) can facilitate the transition. We tested whether ETPTs and clinician reminders increase the frequency of transition discussions during adolescent well-visits.
In an academic adolescent medicine primary care practice serving a predominantly African American, Medicaid-insured population, we developed 4 ETPTs-readiness assessment, plan template, information handout, and diagnosis code. We used Plan-Do-Study-Act quality improvement cycles to implement ETPTs and measure outcomes. Each cycle added a new layer of clinician support: (1) ETPT training, (2) visual reminders, (3) incentives, and (4) daily reminders. The primary outcome was the proportion of well-visits in which "any ETPT use" occurred. We collected data via chart review and used run charts and regression analyses with multiple comparisons to detect differences between cycles. Clinicians-provided feedback was elicited.
Any ETPT use increased from 0% to 45% between baseline and cycle 4. The odds of any ETPT use was ten times larger in cycle 4 compared to cycle 1 (odds ratio 10.09, 95% confidence interval 2.29-44.44, = 0.002) and 22 times larger in cycle 4 than cycle 2 (odds ratio 21.99, 95% confidence interval 3.96-122.00, < 0.001). Clinicians identified time constraints and lack of sociocultural relevance as barriers to uptake.
Daily reminders combined with training and visual reminders were effective in increasing the use of ETPTs in primary care. Future interventions should adapt existing transition tools to the needs of target populations and create regular reminders to facilitate uptake.
在初级保健中,从儿科护理向成人护理的过渡研究不足。电子健康记录集成的过渡计划工具(ETPTs)有助于实现这种过渡。我们测试了ETPTs和临床医生提醒是否能增加青少年健康检查期间过渡讨论的频率。
在一家主要为非裔美国人、参保医疗补助的学术性青少年医学初级保健机构中,我们开发了4种ETPTs——准备情况评估、计划模板、信息手册和诊断代码。我们使用计划-执行-研究-改进质量改进循环来实施ETPTs并衡量结果。每个循环都增加了一层新的临床医生支持:(1)ETPT培训,(2)视觉提醒,(3)激励措施,(4)每日提醒。主要结果是出现“任何ETPT使用”的健康检查比例。我们通过病历审查收集数据,并使用运行图和多重比较的回归分析来检测各循环之间的差异。我们还征求了临床医生的反馈意见。
在基线和第4个循环之间,任何ETPT的使用从0%增加到了45%。与第1个循环相比,第4个循环中任何ETPT使用的几率高出10倍(优势比10.09,95%置信区间2.29 - 44.44,P = 0.002),比第2个循环高出22倍(优势比21.99,95%置信区间3.96 - 122.00,P < 0.001)。临床医生指出时间限制和缺乏社会文化相关性是采用这些工具的障碍。
每日提醒结合培训和视觉提醒有效地增加了初级保健中ETPTs的使用。未来的干预措施应使现有的过渡工具适应目标人群的需求,并设置定期提醒以促进采用。