Department of Psychology, Dalian Medical University, Dalian, China.
Department of Neurology and Psychiatry, First Affiliated Hospital, Dalian Medical University, Dalian, China.
Psychophysiology. 2020 Oct;57(10):e13638. doi: 10.1111/psyp.13638. Epub 2020 Jul 16.
Expected reward and risk (reward variance) are two fundamental parameters in decision making, which may be encoded by distinct functional brain networks during the anticipatory phase of reward processing. However, whether and how anticipatory reward and risk processing are dissociable in terms of temporal dynamics remain ambiguous. The current event-related potential (ERP) study addressed this issue in a card-guessing task where participants were presented sequentially two cards from a deck of nine (numbered 1 through 9) and were instructed to bet whether the second card was higher or lower than the first one. Expected reward and risk were manipulated orthogonally (in an uncorrelated way) over a full range of reward probabilities (every 12.5% from 0% to 100%). We focused on three anticipatory ERP components: the cue-related reward positivity (cue-RewP), the cue-related P3 (cue-P3), and the stimulus-preceding negativity (SPN). During the period after presentation of the first card, the cue-RewP was sensitive to expected reward instead of risk, whereas the cue-P3 was mainly sensitive to risk and to a lesser extent to expected reward. During the waiting period for the second card, the SPN was sensitive to expected reward but not to risk. Our findings indicate a partial neural dissociation between expected reward and risk in the anticipatory phase of reward processing.
期望奖励和风险(奖励方差)是决策的两个基本参数,它们可能在奖励处理的预期阶段通过不同的功能大脑网络进行编码。然而,在时间动态方面,预期奖励和风险处理是否以及如何可分离仍然不清楚。本事件相关电位(ERP)研究在一个卡片猜测任务中解决了这个问题,在该任务中,参与者依次呈现一副牌中的两张牌(编号 1 至 9),并被指示猜测第二张牌是否高于或低于第一张牌。期望奖励和风险以正交的方式(以不相关的方式)在整个奖励概率范围内(从 0%到 100%,每 12.5%)进行操纵。我们关注三个预期 ERP 成分:与线索相关的奖励正波(cue-RewP)、与线索相关的 P3(cue-P3)和刺激前负性(SPN)。在第一张牌呈现后的时间段内,cue-RewP 对期望奖励敏感,而不是风险,而 cue-P3 主要对风险敏感,对期望奖励的敏感性较小。在等待第二张牌的期间,SPN 对期望奖励敏感,但对风险不敏感。我们的发现表明,在奖励处理的预期阶段,期望奖励和风险之间存在部分神经分离。