Mumtaz Nazia, Saqulain Ghulam
Dr. Nazia Mumtaz, PhD (Rehabilitation Sciences). Head of Department of Speech Language Pathology, Faculty of Rehabilitation & Allied Health Sciences, Riphah International University, Lahore, Pakistan.
Dr. Ghulam Saqulain, FCPS (Otorhinolaryngology). Head of Department, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Capital Hospital, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2020 Jul-Aug;36(5):1036-1041. doi: 10.12669/pjms.36.5.1965.
To investigate the Barriers and Priorities accorded by hospital and health administrators to neo-natal hearing screening.
This qualitative exploratory descriptive study employing purposive sampling technique was conducted in Islamabad, over a period of 18 months from 1st August 2015 to 31st January 2017. Sample included the stakeholders i.e., Heads of public sector hospitals of Islamabad including Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, Capital Hospital, and Federal Government Services Hospital, Islamabad. Study included in depth interviews using a self-structured interview guide and audio recording. Recorded data was transcribed followed by thematic analyses which was manually drawn and verified.
The Outcomes from thematic analysis were drawn as Planning, Essential requirements for NNHS, High risk screening, education, Existence of skilled maternal & newborn health workers. Hearing screening equipment//facility instrumentation, Logistic support, Health ministry support and Financial cover are also significant outcomes. Lack of awareness in the public and professionals regarding the importance of early identification of HI, poor health infrastructure, burden on tertiary care and lack of referral top the list of barriers to initiation of NNHS program at hospital administrative level.
The Barriers to NNHS identified at Hospital and Health care administrator level include lack of awareness, poor health infrastructure, burden on tertiary care and lack of referrals. Inherent barriers to NNHS cover the spectrum of lack of liaison/ linkages between obstetrics and other departments, deliveries at homes especially in rural areas, poor follow-up, scarcity of technical and adequately trained manpower. Intangible barriers to NNHS comprise lack of health care information system, attitudinal barriers, inadequate fiscal resources, and lack of integrated approach at intra departmental levels.
调查医院和卫生管理人员对新生儿听力筛查的障碍及优先事项。
本定性探索性描述性研究采用立意抽样技术,于2015年8月1日至2017年1月31日在伊斯兰堡进行,为期18个月。样本包括利益相关者,即伊斯兰堡公立部门医院的负责人,包括巴基斯坦医学科学研究所、首都医院和伊斯兰堡联邦政府服务医院。研究包括使用自行构建的访谈指南和录音进行深度访谈。记录的数据进行转录,随后进行主题分析,主题分析是手动绘制并验证的。
主题分析的结果包括规划、新生儿听力筛查的基本要求、高风险筛查、教育、熟练的母婴健康工作者的存在。听力筛查设备//设施仪器、后勤支持、卫生部支持和资金覆盖也是重要结果。公众和专业人员对早期识别听力损失重要性的认识不足、卫生基础设施差、三级护理负担以及缺乏转诊是医院行政层面启动新生儿听力筛查项目的障碍清单中的首要问题。
在医院和医疗管理人员层面确定的新生儿听力筛查障碍包括认识不足、卫生基础设施差、三级护理负担和缺乏转诊。新生儿听力筛查的内在障碍包括产科与其他部门之间缺乏联络/联系、在家分娩尤其是在农村地区、随访不佳、技术和训练有素的人力短缺。新生儿听力筛查的无形障碍包括缺乏医疗保健信息系统、态度障碍、财政资源不足以及部门内部缺乏综合方法。