From the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, New York University Langone Health, New York, NY.
J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2020 Oct 1;28(19):e860-e864. doi: 10.5435/JAAOS-D-20-00579.
The purpose of the current study was to evaluate resident, fellow, and attending perspectives on the use of e-learning as part of orthopaedic surgery education.
A survey was created evaluating (1) overall attitudes toward e-learning, (2) multi-institutional e-learning/e-conferences, (3) national/regional e-conferences, and (4) future directions with e-learning. The survey was distributed to all the orthopaedic surgery residency program directors in the United States, and they were asked to circulate the survey to their program's faculty and trainees.
A total of 268 responses were collected, including 100 attendings and 168 trainees. Overall satisfaction with e-learning compared with in-person learning was higher among trainees than attending faculty, with 51.4% of trainees favoring e-learning, as opposed to 32.2% of attendings (P = 0.006). Both groups felt they were more likely to pay attention with in-person learning (P = 0.89). During the COVID-19 pandemic, 85.7% of residents have used e-learning platforms to join a conference in their specialty of interest while off-service. Most attendings and trainees felt e-learning should play a supplemental role in standard residency/fellowship education, with a low number of respondents feeling that it should not be used (86.6% versus 84%, and 2.1% versus 0.6%, respectively, P = 0.28).
E-learning has been an important modality to continue academic pursuits during the disruption in usual education and training schedules during the COVID-19 pandemic. Most trainees and attendings surveyed felt that e-learning should play a supplementary role in resident and fellow education moving forward. Although e-learning does provide an opportunity to hold multi-institutional conferences and makes participation in meetings logistically easier, it cannot fully replicate the dynamic interactions and benefits of in-person learning.
本研究旨在评估住院医师、研究员和主治医生对将电子学习作为骨科手术教育的一部分的看法。
创建了一项调查,评估(1)对电子学习的总体态度,(2)多机构电子学习/电子会议,(3)国家/地区电子会议,以及(4)电子学习的未来方向。该调查分发给美国所有的骨科住院医师培训项目主任,并要求他们将调查分发给他们项目的教师和学员。
共收集了 268 份回复,其中包括 100 名主治医生和 168 名学员。与面授学习相比,学员对电子学习的总体满意度高于主治医生,51.4%的学员赞成电子学习,而只有 32.2%的主治医生赞成(P = 0.006)。两组人都认为面授学习更能集中注意力(P = 0.89)。在 COVID-19 大流行期间,85.7%的住院医师在休班期间使用电子学习平台参加自己专业感兴趣的会议。大多数主治医生和学员认为电子学习应在标准住院医师/研究员教育中发挥补充作用,只有少数受访者认为不应使用电子学习(分别为 86.6%和 84%,2.1%和 0.6%,P = 0.28)。
在 COVID-19 大流行打乱正常教育和培训计划期间,电子学习是继续学术追求的重要模式。大多数接受调查的住院医师和主治医生认为,电子学习应在住院医师和研究员教育中发挥补充作用。尽管电子学习确实提供了举办多机构会议的机会,并使参加会议在后勤方面更加容易,但它无法完全复制面对面学习的动态互动和益处。