is Assistant Professor of Clinical Emergency Medicine and Associate Director, Residency Training Program, Department of Emergency Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Ronald Reagan/Olive View, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, Los Angeles, California, USA.
is Assistant Professor of Family Medicine and Program Director, Addiction Medicine Fellowship, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, Oregon, USA.
J Grad Med Educ. 2024 Feb;16(1):75-79. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-23-00208.1. Epub 2024 Feb 17.
Curriculum development is an essential domain for medical educators, yet specific training in this area is inconsistent. With competing demands for educators' time, a succinct resource for best practice is needed. To create a curated list of the most essential articles on curriculum development to guide education scholars in graduate medical education. We used a modified Delphi method, a systematic consensus strategy to increase content validity, to achieve consensus on the most essential curriculum development articles. We convened a panel of 8 experts from the United States in curricular development, with diverse career stages, institutions, gender, and specialty. We conducted a literature search across PubMed and Google Scholar with keywords, such as "curriculum development" and "curricular design," to identify relevant articles focusing on a general overview or approach to curriculum development. Articles were reviewed across 3 iterative Delphi rounds to narrow down those that should be included in a list of the most essential articles on curriculum development. Our literature search yielded 1708 articles, 90 of which were selected for full-text review, and 26 of which were identified as appropriate for the modified Delphi process. We had a 100% response rate for each Delphi round. The panelists narrowed the articles to a final list of 5 articles, with 4 focusing on the development of new curriculum and 1 on curriculum renewal. We developed a curated list of 5 essential articles on curriculum development that is broadly applicable to graduate medical educators.
课程开发是医学教育者的重要领域,但该领域的特定培训并不一致。由于教育者的时间竞争激烈,因此需要一个简洁的最佳实践资源。 为了指导研究生医学教育领域的教育学者,我们创建了一个精心挑选的关于课程开发的最主要文章列表。 我们使用了一种经过修改的 Delphi 方法,这是一种系统的共识策略,可以提高内容的有效性,以就最主要的课程开发文章达成共识。我们召集了来自美国的 8 名课程开发专家组成了一个小组,他们具有不同的职业阶段、机构、性别和专业。我们在 PubMed 和 Google Scholar 上进行了文献搜索,使用了“课程开发”和“课程设计”等关键词,以确定关注课程开发一般概述或方法的相关文章。文章经过 3 轮迭代 Delphi 审查,以缩小应列入课程开发最主要文章列表的范围。 我们的文献搜索产生了 1708 篇文章,其中 90 篇被选为全文审查,26 篇被确定适合修改后的 Delphi 过程。我们对每个 Delphi 轮次的回复率均为 100%。小组成员将文章缩小到最终的 5 篇文章列表,其中 4 篇专注于新课程的开发,1 篇专注于课程更新。 我们开发了一个精心挑选的关于课程开发的 5 篇主要文章列表,这些文章广泛适用于研究生医学教育者。