Institute for Medical Education, Department for Assessment and Evaluation, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Hamburg, Germany.
Med Teach. 2020 Oct;42(10):1163-1170. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2020.1798911. Epub 2020 Aug 8.
Only a few studies have described the impacts, strengths and needs for further development of national licensing exams (NLE). To gain such insights regarding the Swiss NLE, which includes a multiple-choice and a standardised clinical skills exam, we explored the perceptions of involved experts and stakeholders.
We explored participants' perceptions in four focus group discussions. The interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim and qualitatively analysed using a thematic analysis approach.
The analysis resulted in five perceived impacts, two strengths and two needs for further developments of the NLE. Perceived impacts were (1) steering students' learning behaviour, (2) supporting teachers and assessors to align teaching to competencies, (3) elevating the importance of the Swiss Catalogue of Learning Objectives, (4) setting incentives for the further development of curricula, and (5) fostering the collaboration between the faculties of medicine. Perceived strengths were the blend of assessment formats, including their competency-based orientation, and the collaborative development approach. Perceived needs lay in the NLE's further development to sustain its fit for purpose and in incentives for people involved.
According to our study, this NLE had, and has, notable impacts on medical education in Switzerland. Our insights can be useful for others planning a similar undertaking.
仅有少数研究描述了国家执照考试(NLE)的影响、优势和进一步发展的需求。为了深入了解包括多项选择和标准化临床技能考试在内的瑞士 NLE,我们探讨了相关专家和利益相关者的看法。
我们在四个焦点小组讨论中探讨了参与者的看法。对访谈进行了录音、逐字转录,并使用主题分析方法进行定性分析。
分析得出了五项感知到的影响、两个优势和两个进一步发展 NLE 的需求。感知到的影响包括:(1)引导学生的学习行为,(2)支持教师和评估者将教学与能力相匹配,(3)提高瑞士学习目标目录的重要性,(4)为课程进一步发展设置激励措施,以及(5)促进医学院之间的合作。感知到的优势在于评估形式的融合,包括其基于能力的导向,以及协作式的发展方法。感知到的需求在于 NLE 的进一步发展,以维持其适用性,并为相关人员提供激励。
根据我们的研究,该 NLE 对瑞士医学教育产生了重大影响,并将继续产生影响。我们的见解对于计划类似工作的其他人可能会有所帮助。