Corbani Karim, Hardan Louis, Skienhe Hasan, Özcan Mutlu, Alharbi Nawal, Salameh Ziad
Int J Comput Dent. 2020;23(3):225-233.
To evaluate the fracture resistance and failure pattern of 3D-printed and milled composite resin crowns as a function of different material thicknesses.
Three typodont tooth models were prepared to receive a full coverage composite resin crown with different thicknesses (0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 mm). The prepared master casts were digitally scanned using an intraoral scanner, and the STL files were used to fabricate 60 nanocomposite crowns divided into two groups according to the material thickness (n = 10) and fabrication method: a 3D-printed group (3D) using an SLA printer with nanocomposite, and a milled group (M) using a milling machine and composite blocks. All crowns were adhesively seated on stereolithography (SLA)-fabricated dies. All samples were subjected to thermomechanical loading and fracture testing. The load to fracture [N] was recorded and the failure pattern evaluated. Data were statistically analyzed using a two-way ANOVA followed by a Bonferroni post hoc test. The level of significance was set at α = 0.05.
The 3D group showed the highest values for fracture resistance compared with the milled group within the three tested thicknesses (P < 0.001). The 3D and M groups presented significantly higher load to fracture for the 1.5-mm thickness (2383.5 ± 188.58 N and 1284.7 ± 77.62 N, respectively) compared with the 1.0-mm thickness (1945.9 ± 65.32 N and 932.1 ± 41.29 N, respectively) and the 0.5-mm thickness, which showed the lowest values in both groups (1345.0 ± 101.15 N and 519.3 ± 32.96 N, respectively). A higher incidence of irreparable fractures was observed for the 1.5-mm thickness.
3D-printed composite resin crowns showed high fracture resistance at different material thicknesses and can be suggested as a viable solution in conservative dentistry.
评估3D打印和铣削复合树脂全冠的抗折性及失败模式与不同材料厚度的关系。
制备三个典型牙模型,用于制作不同厚度(0.5、1.0和1.5毫米)的全冠复合树脂全冠。使用口内扫描仪对制备好的主模型进行数字化扫描,将STL文件用于制作60个纳米复合树脂全冠,根据材料厚度(n = 10)和制作方法分为两组:使用纳米复合树脂的SLA打印机进行3D打印的组(3D组),以及使用铣床和复合树脂块的铣削组(M组)。所有全冠均通过粘接固定在立体光刻(SLA)制作的代型上。对所有样本进行热机械加载和抗折测试。记录抗折载荷[N]并评估失败模式。数据采用双向方差分析,随后进行Bonferroni事后检验进行统计学分析。显著性水平设定为α = 0.05。
在三种测试厚度下,3D组的抗折性值均高于铣削组(P < 0.001)。与1.0毫米厚度(分别为1945.9 ± 65.32 N和932.1 ± 41.29 N)和0.5毫米厚度(两组中该厚度的值最低,分别为1345.0 ± 101.15 N和519.3 ± 32.96 N)相比,3D组和M组在1.5毫米厚度时的抗折载荷显著更高(分别为2383.5 ± 188.58 N和1284.7 ± 77.62 N)。1.5毫米厚度时观察到的不可修复性骨折发生率更高。
3D打印复合树脂全冠在不同材料厚度下均表现出较高的抗折性,可作为保守牙科领域的可行解决方案。