Dept of Clinical Studies, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Guelph, ON, Canada.
Dept of Clinical Studies, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Guelph, ON, Canada.
J Equine Vet Sci. 2020 Sep;92:103176. doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2020.103176. Epub 2020 Jun 20.
The accuracy of using radiographs to diagnose cervical facet osteoarthritis (CFA) in horses is undetermined. Further investigation is required to determine the clinical significance of radiographic evidence of CFA, the prevalence of radiographic changes in horses without clinical signs, and the long-term efficacy of intra-articular CFA treatment. The objectives of this study is to compare degenerative changes of the cervical facet joints of the cervical vertebrae on radiographs of horses with clinical signs of CFA with healthy cohort-matched horses, to compare clinical findings between groups, and to obtain follow-up information on the long-term outcome in treated horses. This is a retrospective case-control cohort-matched comparison study of horses treated for cervical facet disease versus horses with no clinical signs of cervical facet disease. Horses diagnosed with CFA and treated with intra-articular injection of corticosteroids were included. Follow-up information on recovery from treatment was obtained via telephone survey of owners/trainers. Healthy horses with no clinical signs of CFA were matched to treated horses by breed, sex, age, and sport as the control group. Two blinded radiologists reviewed cervical spine radiographs for each horse and recorded CFA score and intravertebral/intervertebral measurements. Clinical and radiographic parameters were compared between treatment and control groups. There was a significant difference in CFA grades for C5-6 and C6-7 between horses with presence of clinical signs and healthy horses. However, interobserver agreement between radiologists for grading CFA was moderate and only 56% of values were identical for both observers. Atrophy of the neck was present on clinical examination in most cases in the treatment group. Dressage horses were overrepresented. Overall, 64% of horses returned to their previous level of performance after treatment. Clinical examination data collected for the treatment group were retrospective and were obtained by different clinicians. Eight owners/trainers were not able to be reached for the survey. There was a significant difference in CFA grades for C5-6 and C6-7 between horses with presence of clinical signs and healthy horses. Despite these statistical differences, the clinical diagnosis of CFA based on radiographic grading alone is questionable because of the lack of agreement between the radiologists. To strengthen the diagnosis, clinical signs of facet disease, in particular atrophy of the neck muscles, need to be present to make this diagnosis. Intra-articular corticosteroid injection was effective at allowing most treated horses to return to athletic use..
使用 X 光片诊断马颈椎小面关节炎(CFA)的准确性尚未确定。需要进一步研究以确定 CFA 的 X 光证据的临床意义、无临床症状的马匹 X 光变化的发生率以及关节内 CFA 治疗的长期疗效。本研究的目的是比较有临床症状的 CFA 马和健康对照组马颈椎小面关节的退行性变化,比较两组的临床发现,并获得治疗后长期结果的随访信息。这是一项回顾性病例对照队列匹配研究,比较了接受颈椎小面疾病治疗的马匹与无颈椎小面疾病临床症状的马匹。纳入了诊断为 CFA 并接受关节内皮质类固醇注射治疗的马匹。通过对马主/教练进行电话调查获得治疗后恢复情况的随访信息。健康无 CFA 临床症状的马匹根据品种、性别、年龄和运动与治疗马相匹配作为对照组。两名盲法放射科医生对每匹马的颈椎 X 光片进行评估,并记录 CFA 评分和椎内/椎间测量值。比较治疗组和对照组的临床和放射学参数。有临床症状的马匹与健康马匹的 C5-6 和 C6-7 小面关节炎分级有显著差异。然而,放射科医生对 CFA 分级的观察者间一致性为中度,只有 56%的数值对两名观察者都相同。在治疗组,大多数病例的颈部萎缩在临床检查中都存在。盛装舞步马的比例过高。总体而言,64%的马匹在治疗后恢复到以前的运动水平。为治疗组收集的临床检查数据是回顾性的,由不同的临床医生获得。有 8 位马主/教练无法接受调查。有临床症状的马匹与健康马匹的 C5-6 和 C6-7 小面关节炎分级有显著差异。尽管存在这些统计学差异,但由于放射科医生之间缺乏一致性,仅凭放射学分级对 CFA 的临床诊断值得怀疑。为了加强诊断,需要存在小面关节疾病的临床症状,特别是颈部肌肉萎缩,才能做出此诊断。关节内皮质类固醇注射可有效使大多数接受治疗的马匹恢复运动能力。
J Vet Intern Med. 2024
Animals (Basel). 2021-2-6