Hong Kris Y, Pinheiro Pedro O, Weichenthal Scott
McGill University, Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupational Health, Montreal, QC H3A 1A3, Canada; Element AI, 6650 Saint Urbain, Suite #500, Montreal, QC H2S 3G9, Canada.
Element AI, 6650 Saint Urbain, Suite #500, Montreal, QC H2S 3G9, Canada.
Environ Int. 2020 Nov;144:106044. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2020.106044. Epub 2020 Aug 14.
Outdoor ultrafine particles (UFPs) (<0.1 µm) may have an important impact on public health but exposure assessment remains a challenge in epidemiological studies. We developed a novel method of estimating spatiotemporal variations in outdoor UFP number concentrations and particle diameters using street-level images and audio data in Montreal, Canada. As a secondary aim, we also developed models for noise. Convolutional neural networks were first trained to predict 10-second average UFP/noise parameters using a large database of images and audio spectrogram data paired with measurements collected between April 2019 and February 2020. Final multivariable linear regression and generalized additive models were developed to predict 5-minute average UFP/noise parameters including covariates from deep learning models based on image and audio data along with outdoor temperature and wind speed. The best performing final models had mean cross-validation R values of 0.677 and 0.523 for UFP number concentrations and 0.825 and 0.735 for UFP size using two different test sets. Audio predictions from deep learning models were stronger predictors of spatiotemporal variations in UFP parameters than predictions based on street-level images; this was not explained only by noise levels captured in the audio signal. All final noise models had R values above 0.90. Collectively, our findings suggest that street-level images and audio data can be used to estimate spatiotemporal variations in outdoor UFPs and noise. This approach may be useful in developing exposure models over broad spatial scales and such models can be regularly updated to expand generalizability as more measurements become available.
室外超细颗粒物(UFPs,直径<0.1微米)可能对公众健康产生重大影响,但在流行病学研究中,暴露评估仍是一项挑战。我们开发了一种新方法,利用加拿大蒙特利尔市的街道级图像和音频数据,估算室外超细颗粒物数量浓度和粒径的时空变化。作为次要目标,我们还开发了噪声模型。首先,利用2019年4月至2020年2月期间收集的图像和音频频谱图数据与测量数据配对的大型数据库,训练卷积神经网络来预测10秒平均超细颗粒物/噪声参数。最终开发了多变量线性回归和广义相加模型,以预测5分钟平均超细颗粒物/噪声参数,包括基于图像和音频数据的深度学习模型的协变量,以及室外温度和风速。使用两个不同测试集,表现最佳的最终模型对超细颗粒物数量浓度的平均交叉验证R值分别为0.677和0.523,对超细颗粒物粒径的平均交叉验证R值分别为0.825和0.735。与基于街道级图像的预测相比,深度学习模型的音频预测是超细颗粒物参数时空变化的更强预测指标;这不仅仅由音频信号中捕获的噪声水平来解释。所有最终噪声模型的R值均高于0.90。总体而言,我们的研究结果表明,街道级图像和音频数据可用于估算室外超细颗粒物和噪声的时空变化。这种方法可能有助于在广泛的空间尺度上开发暴露模型,并且随着更多测量数据的获得,此类模型可以定期更新以扩大其通用性。