Daniell W E, Couser W G, Rosenstock L
Department of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle 98195.
JAMA. 1988 Apr 15;259(15):2280-3.
We describe a patient who presented with renal failure after a one-year period of unprotected heavy occupational exposure to organic solvents. Renal biopsy results and serological findings were diagnostic of anti-glomerular basement membrane antibody-mediated glomerulonephritis. An analytic review of the literature revealed substantial evidence linking solvent exposure to the development of glomerulonephritis (GN), with seven of nine case-control studies demonstrating a statistically significant association. Odds ratios were reported by or could be calculated for six of these studies, and the five positive studies detected a 2.8- to 8.9-fold increased risk for GN among solvent-exposed individuals. The findings in several of these studies of dose-response relationships, the reports of variations in disease severity in relation to exposure intensity, and the absence of alternative explanations for the association provide additional supportive evidence for a solvent effect. In the majority of cases of anti-glomerular basement membrane antibody-mediated GN and other types of GN, there is no remarkable preceding exposure to organic solvents. However, we conclude that in the case presented herein and in cases of GN with similar exposure histories, solvent exposure may play a significant contributing role in the development of GN.
我们描述了一名患者,其在一年无防护的大量职业性接触有机溶剂后出现肾衰竭。肾活检结果和血清学检查结果诊断为抗肾小球基底膜抗体介导的肾小球肾炎。对文献的分析性回顾显示,有大量证据表明溶剂接触与肾小球肾炎(GN)的发生有关,9项病例对照研究中有7项显示出统计学上的显著关联。其中6项研究报告了比值比或可计算出比值比,5项阳性研究发现溶剂接触个体患GN的风险增加了2.8至8.9倍。这些研究中的几项关于剂量反应关系的发现、疾病严重程度与接触强度相关变化的报告以及该关联不存在其他解释,为溶剂效应提供了额外的支持证据。在大多数抗肾小球基底膜抗体介导的GN和其他类型GN病例中,之前没有明显的有机溶剂接触史。然而,我们得出结论,在本文所述病例以及具有类似接触史的GN病例中,溶剂接触可能在GN的发生中起重要的促成作用。