Department of Pediatrics, Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina.
J Public Health Manag Pract. 2022;28(1):E155-E161. doi: 10.1097/PHH.0000000000001223.
We used public data from 2 national surveys to determine how survey mode and questionnaire wording potentially impact estimated prevalence and predictors of children's unmet health care needs.
Data from 2016-2017 were obtained for the National Health Interview Survey (NHIS), where interviewers ask caregivers about each type of unmet health care need in person, and the National Survey of Children's Health (NSCH), a self-administered questionnaire asking a general question about any unmet health care needs, with subparts about specific types of unmet needs. Weighted proportions and multivariable logistic regression were used to analyze each data set.
The weighted proportion of any unmet health care needs was significantly higher in the NHIS (7.5%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 7.0-8.1; N = 17 723) than in the NSCH (3.3%; 95% CI, 2.9-3.7; N = 65 766). When analyzing specific unmet needs, unmet need for dental care was significantly higher according to the NHIS (4.2% vs 1.9% in the NSCH), as was unmet need for vision care (1.7% vs 0.8%). Conversely, estimates of unmet need for medical care were comparable between the surveys (1.4% and 1.0%). On multivariable analysis, predictors of unmet health care needs, such as being uninsured, had effect sizes of similar magnitude in both surveys.
The NHIS design, asking about each type of unmet need in person, may have been more conducive to identifying the full range of unmet health care needs among children. However, our results did not indicate that this was a source of bias in multivariable regression analysis.
我们利用两项全国性调查的公开数据,来确定调查方式和问卷措辞如何潜在影响儿童卫生服务需求未满足情况的估计流行率及其预测因素。
我们获取了 2016-2017 年全国健康访谈调查(NHIS)和全国儿童健康调查(NSCH)的数据。在 NHIS 中,调查员亲自询问照护者每种类型的卫生服务需求未满足情况;而 NSCH 则采用自填式问卷,询问儿童是否存在任何卫生服务需求未满足情况,如果有则进一步询问特定类型的未满足需求。我们使用加权比例和多变量逻辑回归分析来分析每个数据集。
NHIS 中任何卫生服务需求未满足情况的加权比例(7.5%;95%置信区间[CI],7.0-8.1;N=17723)显著高于 NSCH(3.3%;95% CI,2.9-3.7;N=65766)。在分析特定的未满足需求时,NHIS 报告的牙科保健需求未满足率(4.2%)显著高于 NSCH(1.9%),视力保健需求未满足率(1.7%)也高于 NSCH(0.8%)。相反,两项调查中医疗保健需求未满足率的估计值相当(1.4%和 1.0%)。在多变量分析中,卫生服务需求未满足的预测因素,如没有医疗保险,在两项调查中的效应大小相似。
NHIS 的设计通过当面询问每种类型的未满足需求,可能更有利于确定儿童卫生服务需求未满足的全貌。然而,我们的结果并未表明这是多变量回归分析中出现偏倚的一个来源。