Tangney C C
Department of Foods & Nutrition, University of North Carolina at Greensboro 27412-5001.
Prog Clin Biol Res. 1988;259:331-62.
AA analyses are rife with problems - but primarily stability of the sample AA and specificity are the most prevalent shortcomings of the assays reviewed. Should one desire to quantify AA alone with no consideration for DHAA or DKG, chromatographic separations such as those described by Nahrwold (1981) with reductants added to samples and standards using UV detection, or Iwata et al. (1985) with fluorescence or Tsao and Salimi (1982) with EC detection would probably be appropriate depending upon the equipment available. The initial preparation of sample must be tested to ensure that no spontaneous oxidation of AA occurs during the sample preparation. The main advantage of these chromatographic assays is simply that one is measuring AA directly. On the other hand, manual assays such as that proposed by Zannoni et al. (1974) or Samyn (1983) have apparently demonstrated sufficient specificity and sensitivity to be used as well. When other vitamin C compounds need to be quantified, chromatographic assays should be considered but the selection is largely dependant on the sample size (and thus sensitivity required), the possible interfering compounds, and the detector available. Ideally HPLC should ensure the specificity by resolving the compounds of interest from artifacts. However, the optical characteristics of DHAA and DKG which are quite different from that of AA and detection limitations have fostered a number of complicated manipulations to quantify the former.
抗坏血酸(AA)分析存在诸多问题——但在所审查的分析方法中,样本中AA的稳定性和特异性是最普遍的缺点。如果只想单独定量AA而不考虑脱氢抗坏血酸(DHAA)或二酮古洛糖酸(DKG),那么根据可用设备,诸如Nahrwold(1981年)所述的在样本和标准品中添加还原剂并使用紫外检测的色谱分离法,或Iwata等人(1985年)使用荧光检测的方法,或Tsao和Salimi(1982年)使用电化学检测的方法可能是合适的。样本的初始制备必须经过测试,以确保在样本制备过程中AA不会发生自发氧化。这些色谱分析方法的主要优点仅仅是可以直接测量AA。另一方面,诸如Zannoni等人(1974年)或Samyn(1983年)提出的手动分析方法显然也已证明具有足够的特异性和灵敏度,也可使用。当需要对其他维生素C化合物进行定量时,应考虑采用色谱分析方法,但选择很大程度上取决于样本量(以及因此所需的灵敏度)、可能的干扰化合物以及可用的检测器。理想情况下,高效液相色谱(HPLC)应通过将目标化合物与假象物分离来确保特异性。然而,DHAA和DKG的光学特性与AA有很大不同,且检测存在局限性,这促使人们进行了许多复杂的操作来定量前者。