Messner Mitchell K, Chong Alexander C M, Piatt Bruce E
University of North Dakota, School of Medicine & Health Sciences, Grand Forks, ND.
Department of Graduate Medical Education, Sanford Health, Fargo, ND.
Kans J Med. 2020 Aug 17;13:195-201. eCollection 2020.
Smokers and nicotine users have a higher risk of femoral neck fracture non-union and prolonged time to fracture union. The impact of smoking resulting in revision surgery after fixation of femoral neck fractures, however, rarely has been studied. The aim of this retrospective study was to review if cigarette smoking had an influence on re-operation and revision after femoral neck fracture treatment.
Three groups of patients (Group 1: active smokers; Group 2: former smokers; and Group 3: non-smokers) who sustained a femoral neck fracture from January 2012 through August 2018 were included. Outcomes investigated included femoral neck fracture type, operative fixation type, fixation failure, and time interval between initial fixation and revision.
A total of 1,452 subjects were identified (Group 1: 165 subjects; Group 2: 507 subjects; and Group 3: 780 subjects). In the male population, Groups 1 and 2 had higher rates of femoral neck fracture than Group 3. Twelve cases required revisions (Group 1: three cases (6%); Group 2: two cases (2%); Group 3: seven cases (4%)), with all but one revision within the first year following initial fixation. Group 1 patients tended to be younger than the other two groups.
Smoking has a positive association with the risk of femoral neck fracture amongst active and former male smokers. This study concluded that active smokers have a higher risk of non-union compared with non-smokers or former smokers. Smoking history, especially heavy or long-term, should play a role in deciding which fixation construct type to use for femoral neck fractures.
吸烟者和使用尼古丁者发生股骨颈骨折不愈合及骨折愈合时间延长的风险更高。然而,吸烟对股骨颈骨折内固定术后翻修手术的影响鲜有研究。本回顾性研究的目的是探讨吸烟是否会对股骨颈骨折治疗后的再次手术和翻修产生影响。
纳入2012年1月至2018年8月期间发生股骨颈骨折的三组患者(第1组:现吸烟者;第2组:既往吸烟者;第3组:不吸烟者)。研究的结果指标包括股骨颈骨折类型、手术内固定类型、内固定失败情况以及初次固定与翻修之间的时间间隔。
共纳入1452例受试者(第1组:165例;第2组:507例;第3组:780例)。在男性人群中,第1组和第2组的股骨颈骨折发生率高于第3组。12例患者需要进行翻修手术(第1组:3例(6%);第2组:2例(2%);第3组:7例(4%)),除1例翻修手术外,其余均在初次固定后的第一年内进行。第1组患者的年龄往往比其他两组患者年轻。
现吸烟和既往吸烟的男性吸烟者发生股骨颈骨折的风险呈正相关。本研究得出结论,与不吸烟者或既往吸烟者相比,现吸烟者发生骨折不愈合的风险更高。吸烟史,尤其是重度或长期吸烟史,在决定股骨颈骨折采用何种内固定方式时应予以考虑。