North A S, Ur-Rehman J, Lin D J
Institute of Health and Society, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK; Department of Otolaryngology, Freeman Hospital, Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK.
Medical School, Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK.
Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020 Dec;58(10):e296-e300. doi: 10.1016/j.bjoms.2020.08.006. Epub 2020 Aug 11.
The British Association of Head and Neck Oncologists (BAHNO) hosts an annual meeting at which research from all specialties involved in the management of head and neck oncology is presented. We have analysed the rate of publication of the abstracts presented, and reviewed the finalised programmes from the meetings between 2009 and 2015. The 2014 meeting was excluded as it was a combined international meeting. Key terms were searched in PubMed and Google Scholar to identify publications in peer-reviewed journals. If none was identified, these platforms were searched for the authors' names. Published abstracts were excluded. Study and journal demographic data were extracted. A total of 363 abstracts were presented, including 75 oral, 271 poster, and 17 of unclear presentation method. The total publication rate was 31.1%, representing 46.7% of oral abstracts and 27.3% of poster presentations. The mean time to publication was 16.5 months. Research was published in 45 individual journals with a mean (range) impact factor of 2.559 (0.886-36.418). There was a trend towards an increasing number of presentations over time with a decreasing publication rate. However, there was no trend in mean impact factor by year. The publication rate of abstracts presented at the BAHNO annual meetings is comparable with that of other large otolaryngology and head and neck conferences. The mean impact factor has not previously been utilised within this field, but may prove a useful metric that enables monitoring of the quality of presented research and comparison of the impact of the conferences.
英国头颈肿瘤学家协会(BAHNO)每年举办一次会议,会上展示了头颈肿瘤管理所有专业领域的研究成果。我们分析了所展示摘要的发表率,并回顾了2009年至2015年会议的最终议程。2014年的会议被排除在外,因为它是一次联合国际会议。在PubMed和谷歌学术中搜索关键词,以确定同行评审期刊上的出版物。如果未找到相关出版物,则在这些平台上搜索作者姓名。已发表的摘要被排除在外。提取了研究和期刊的人口统计学数据。共展示了363篇摘要,包括75篇口头报告、271篇海报展示以及17篇展示方式不明的摘要。总发表率为31.1%,其中口头摘要的发表率为46.7%,海报展示的发表率为27.3%。平均发表时间为16.5个月。研究成果发表在45种不同的期刊上,平均(范围)影响因子为2.559(0.886 - 36.418)。随着时间的推移,展示的报告数量呈增加趋势,而发表率呈下降趋势。然而,按年份计算的平均影响因子没有趋势变化。BAHNO年会展示摘要的发表率与其他大型耳鼻喉科和头颈会议相当。该领域此前未使用过平均影响因子,但它可能是一个有用的指标,可用于监测所展示研究的质量以及比较会议的影响力。