Urology Department, Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt.
World J Urol. 2021 Jun;39(6):2049-2054. doi: 10.1007/s00345-020-03425-3. Epub 2020 Aug 31.
To investigate the efficacy and safety of mirabegron versus solifenacin as add-on for persistent OAB symptoms after tamsulosin monotherapy in men with probable BPO.
This prospective randomized single-blind study was conducted on patients with persistent OAB symptoms after at least 12 weeks of tamsulosin 0.4 mg. The patients were randomized into group A in which mirabegron (50 mg once daily) was added and group B in which solifenacin (5 mg once daily) was added. Before and 12 weeks after addition of either drugs, we assessed the efficacy of the treatment using the OABSS, IPSS, Q max, MVV/mic and PVR.
Ninety two men were included in this study (46 patients in each group). All the study parameters were significantly improved after the 12-week treatment period in both groups except mean PVR which showed non-significant change in group A and a significant change in group B despite of being clinically irrelevant with only one case of acute urine retention. Overall, no significant difference has been observed between both groups after 12 weeks of treatment regarding all studied parameters except PVR. The incidence of side effects in group A was 10.9% versus 26.1% in group B. Main side effects included dry mouth in 2.2% and 8.7% and constipation in 2.2% and 6.5% in group A and B, respectively.
Our results indicate that the addition of either mirabegron or solifenacin to patients with persistent OAB symptoms after tamsulosin monotherapy has significant efficacy in controlling these symptoms. The adequate balance between efficacy and tolerability reported in this study with mirabegron may result in better QOL and overall patient satisfaction if compared with antimuscarinics.
研究米拉贝隆与索利那新作为坦索罗辛单药治疗后持续存在逼尿症症状(OAB)的男性患者(BPO 可能性大)的附加治疗的疗效和安全性。
这项前瞻性随机单盲研究纳入了至少接受坦索罗辛 0.4mg 治疗 12 周后仍持续存在 OAB 症状的患者。患者随机分为 A 组,加用米拉贝隆(50mg,每日一次);B 组,加用索利那新(5mg,每日一次)。在添加任何药物之前和 12 周后,我们使用 OABSS、IPSS、Q max、MVV/mic 和 PVR 评估治疗效果。
本研究共纳入 92 名男性患者(每组 46 名患者)。两组患者的所有研究参数在 12 周治疗后均显著改善,除平均 PVR 外,A 组无显著变化,B 组有显著变化,但仅 1 例发生急性尿潴留,变化具有临床意义。总体而言,两组患者在治疗 12 周后,除 PVR 外,所有研究参数均无显著差异。A 组的不良反应发生率为 10.9%,B 组为 26.1%。主要不良反应包括口干,A 组为 2.2%,B 组为 8.7%;便秘,A 组为 2.2%,B 组为 6.5%。
我们的结果表明,在坦索罗辛单药治疗后持续存在 OAB 症状的患者中,加用米拉贝隆或索利那新治疗具有显著的疗效,可以控制这些症状。与抗毒蕈碱药物相比,米拉贝隆在本研究中报告的疗效和耐受性之间的适当平衡可能会导致更好的生活质量和整体患者满意度。