Department of Radiology, Changi General Hospital, 2 Simei St 3, Singapore 529889, Republic of Singapore.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2020 Nov;215(5):1155-1162. doi: 10.2214/AJR.19.22594. Epub 2020 Sep 9.
Outpatient appointment no-shows are a common problem. Artificial intelligence predictive analytics can potentially facilitate targeted interventions to improve efficiency. We describe a quality improvement project that uses machine learning techniques to predict and reduce outpatient MRI appointment no-shows. Anonymized records from 32,957 outpatient MRI appointments between 2016 and 2018 were acquired for model training and validation along with a holdout test set of 1080 records from January 2019. The overall no-show rate was 17.4%. A predictive model developed with XGBoost, a decision tree-based ensemble machine learning algorithm that uses a gradient boosting framework, was deployed after various machine learning algorithms were evaluated. The simple intervention measure of using telephone call reminders for patients with the top 25% highest risk of an appointment no-show as predicted by the model was implemented over 6 months. The ROC AUC for the predictive model was 0.746 with an optimized F1 score of 0.708; at this threshold, the precision and recall were 0.606 and 0.852, respectively. The AUC for the holdout test set was 0.738 with an optimized F1 score of 0.721; at this threshold, the precision and recall were 0.605 and 0.893, respectively. The no-show rate 6 months after deployment of the predictive model was 15.9% compared with 19.3% in the preceding 12-month preintervention period, corresponding to a 17.2% improvement from the baseline no-show rate ( < 0.0001). The no-show rates of contactable and noncontactable patients in the group at high risk of appointment no-shows as predicted by the model were 17.5% and 40.3%, respectively ( < 0.0001). Machine learning predictive analytics perform moderately well in predicting complex problems involving human behavior using a modest amount of data with basic feature engineering, and they can be incorporated into routine workflow to improve health care delivery.
门诊预约失约是一个常见的问题。人工智能预测分析有可能促进有针对性的干预措施,以提高效率。我们描述了一个使用机器学习技术预测和减少门诊 MRI 预约失约的质量改进项目。我们获取了 2016 年至 2018 年间 32957 次门诊 MRI 预约的匿名记录,用于模型训练和验证,以及 2019 年 1 月的 1080 次记录的保留测试集。总体失约率为 17.4%。使用 XGBoost(一种基于决策树的集成机器学习算法,使用梯度提升框架)开发的预测模型在评估了各种机器学习算法后进行了部署。该模型预测的失约风险最高的前 25%的患者将收到电话提醒,这是一种简单的干预措施,在 6 个月内实施。预测模型的 ROC AUC 为 0.746,优化后的 F1 分数为 0.708;在此阈值下,精度和召回率分别为 0.606 和 0.852。保留测试集的 AUC 为 0.738,优化后的 F1 分数为 0.721;在此阈值下,精度和召回率分别为 0.605 和 0.893。预测模型部署后 6 个月的失约率为 15.9%,而干预前 12 个月的失约率为 19.3%,与基线失约率相比提高了 17.2%(<0.0001)。模型预测的失约风险高的可联系和不可联系患者的失约率分别为 17.5%和 40.3%(<0.0001)。机器学习预测分析在使用基本特征工程处理少量数据来预测涉及人类行为的复杂问题方面表现良好,并且可以将其纳入常规工作流程以改善医疗保健服务。