Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Kokilaben Dhirubai Ambani Hospital and Medical Research Institute, Mumbai, India.
Department of Speech, Language & Hearing Sciences, Sri Ramachandra Institute of Higher Education & Research (Deemed to be University), Chennai, India.
J Voice. 2022 Sep;36(5):732.e1-732.e8. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2020.08.022. Epub 2020 Sep 9.
Frequency range measures in singers reflect their physiological capacity, vocal flexibility, training effects, strengths, and limitations in singing. Since this information is vital for pedagogic and clinical purposes, this study aimed to measure the frequency range in Carnatic singers while singing different aspects of the vocal music.
Practice task (gliding from lowest to highest note) and performance task (singing a song with vocal ornaments) were recorded from 55 trained Carnatic singers (40 females and 15 males). The auditorily verified portions of various vocal ornaments in Carnatic singing (such as aalapanai, pallavi, anupallavi, charanam, and niraval) were coded as separate tokens. A total of 385 tokens were analyzed using PRAAT software for estimating frequency range in semitones during practice task (SFR) and performance task (SFR). Descriptive, ANOVA, Tukey HSD, independent t, and Mann-Whitney U were used for statistical analysis.
SFR was higher than SFR in Carnatic singers. During practice, singers explored their physiological range to improve their vocal ability. However, during performance they tend to maintain a comfortable singing range to have a flawless rendition. Aalapanai (most creative portion) had the highest frequency range (females: 22.96 ST, males: 24.57 ST) than other types of vocal ornaments in performance signing. Practice frequency range (SFR) and performance frequency range (SFR) were not statistically different across male and female singers.
This study described the frequency range measures in various aspects and nuances of Carnatic singing. Its clinical and pedagogic importance are discussed.
歌手的频率范围测量反映了他们的生理能力、发声灵活性、训练效果、歌唱的优势和局限。由于这些信息对教学和临床都至关重要,因此本研究旨在测量卡纳提克歌手在演唱声乐的不同方面时的频率范围。
从 55 位受过训练的卡纳提克歌手(40 位女性和 15 位男性)中录制练习任务(从最低音到最高音滑动)和表演任务(用声乐装饰唱一首歌)。卡纳提克歌唱中的各种声乐装饰(如 aalapanai、pallavi、anupallavi、charanam 和 niraval)的听觉验证部分被编码为单独的标记。使用 Praat 软件分析了总共 385 个标记,以估算练习任务(SFR)和表演任务(SFR)中的半音频率范围。使用描述性统计、方差分析、Tukey HSD、独立 t 检验和 Mann-Whitney U 检验进行统计分析。
卡纳提克歌手的 SFR 高于 SFR。在练习过程中,歌手探索他们的生理范围以提高他们的歌唱能力。然而,在表演过程中,他们倾向于保持舒适的演唱范围以达到完美的演绎。Aalapanai(最具创意的部分)在表演演唱中具有最高的频率范围(女性:22.96 ST,男性:24.57 ST),高于其他类型的声乐装饰。练习频率范围(SFR)和表演频率范围(SFR)在男女歌手之间没有统计学上的差异。
本研究描述了卡纳提克歌唱的各种方面和细微差别中的频率范围测量。讨论了其临床和教学意义。